140 views
Left Foot Forward > Published by Shamik Das, April 6th 2010 at 11:54 am

Cameron fails to say he’s for “gay or straight”

Print Friendly

David Cameron, in a speech to activists on the South Bank, claimed the Tories would be fighting the election “for the great ignored”, claiming his party was for “young or old, rich or poor, black or white…” But he neglected to include “gay or straight” despite briefing the line in advance of his speech, and despite it being on the Tory party website:

DC-straight-gay-screenshot

As Sunder Katwala of the Fabian Society tweeted, it is to be hoped this is just a lapse of memory, and not a message of support to Chris Grayling:

“Cameron dropping ‘straight or gay’ having briefed it surely memory error. But extends No Comment on Grayling & could reanimate it

The fallout from Mr Grayling’s comments continues to drag on for the Conservatives, with a poll of 1,193 gay voters for the Pink News website showing support for the Tories down five points from 25% to 20%, with Labour unchanged on 28% and the Liberal Democrats up five on 29%.

The poll also revealed 30% of gay voters “felt less favourably” towards David Cameron following his recent Gay Times interview in which he failed to commit to a Lords amendment allowing civil partnership ceremonies to be performed on religious premises.

Meanwhile, Compass has launched a petition calling on Mr Cameron to sack Mr Grayling and “clearly state his party’s stance on discrimination” following the shadow home secretary’s remarks over the weekend in which he was secretly recorded telling a right wing think tank that bed and breakfast owners should be allowed to bar gay couples from their premises.

The petition says:

“Will the man who might be our next Prime Minister sit by and silently accept bigotry from his top Shadow Cabinet members, or will he reassure the people of Britain that he means what he says that his party has changed?

“Allowing certain business-owners to discriminate based on sexual orientation opens the door to discrimination based on race, religion, country of origin, and anything else.

“Sign our urgent petition to David Cameron, telling him to sack Chris Grayling and clearly state his party’s stance on discrimination.”

Sign the petition here

  • http://twitter.com/helentrue/status/11692653081 Helen True

    RT @leftfootfwd: Cam fails to say he's for "gay or straight". Unforgivable given concern over Graylings remarks on B&Bs http://bit.ly/b5QOVh

  • http://twitter.com/psbook/status/11693367129 Political Scrapbook

    Cameron omits reference to gay community from speech http://is.gd/bgXm4 (via @leftfootfwd)

  • http://twitter.com/perilouspierre/status/11693656562 Peter Rayner

    RT @WillHeaven: Sharp spot. RT @leftfootfwd Cameron fails to say he's for "gay or straight"… http://bit.ly/b5QOVh

  • topsy_top20k_en

    Cam fails to say he's for "gay or straight". Unforgivable given concern over Graylings remarks on B&Bs http://bit.ly/b5QOVh

  • http://twitter.com/chiefprune/status/11693975470 Clare Gould

    RT @CathElliott: RT @psbook: Cameron omits reference to gay community from speech http://is.gd/bgXm4 (via @leftfootfwd)

  • http://twitter.com/willheaven/status/11692604772 WillHeaven

    Sharp spot. RT @leftfootfwd Cameron fails to say he's for "gay or straight"… http://bit.ly/b5QOVh

  • http://twitter.com/joe_e_coco/status/11692633908 joey coco

    RT @WillHeaven: Sharp spot. RT @leftfootfwd Cameron fails to say he's for "gay or straight"… http://bit.ly/b5QOVh

  • http://twitter.com/ciphergoth/status/11694835563 ciphergoth

    Cameron's speech for the cameras leaves out "gay or straight" http://j.mp/dwWjvg

  • http://twitter.com/his_grace/status/11692832080 Archbishop Cranmer

    Ironic memory lapse? RT @WillHeaven Sharp spot. RT @leftfootfwd Cameron fails to say he's for "gay or straight" http://bit.ly/b5QOVh

  • http://twitter.com/larmitstead/status/11692934619 Louise Armitstead

    Slip of the mind or change of mind? RT @leftfootfwd Cameron fails to say he's for "gay or straight". http://bit.ly/b5QOVh #ukelection

  • http://politicalscrapbook.net/2010/04/gay-support-for-conservatives-plunges-5-points-after-cameron-and-grayling-gaffes/ Gay support for Conservatives plunges 5 points after Cameron and Grayling gaffes | Political Scrapbook

    [...] to the gay community from a speech despite this wording being briefed in advance. Left Foot Forward have the story. Share With Friends Filed under: Uncategorized 4 Comments Comments (0) Trackbacks (4) ( [...]

  • http://twitter.com/tscholesfogg/status/11693388102 Tom Scholes-Fogg

    RT @psbook Cameron omits reference to gay community from speech http://is.gd/bgXm4 (via @leftfootfwd)

  • http://politicalscrapbook.net/ Political Scrapbook

    Outstanding spot from Sunder Katwala on this one.

  • http://twitter.com/cathelliott/status/11693433511 CathElliott

    RT @psbook: Cameron omits reference to gay community from speech http://is.gd/bgXm4 (via @leftfootfwd)

  • http://twitter.com/jacqkelly/status/11693455740 Jacq Kelly

    RT @psbook: Cameron omits reference to gay community from speech http://is.gd/bgXm4 (via @leftfootfwd)

  • Rory

    This argument is in large part about whether or not a bed & breakfast is a business in the same way as a hotel is. Evidently, Mr Grayling is not sure whether it is, hence his equivocation on the issue. In the same way as most would argue that the state cannot interfere in all aspects of life to stamp out bigotry – for example, by stepping in to prevent a father banning his gay son bringing a boyfriend home – Mr Grayling rightly or wrongly seems to think that a B&B should be treated as not just a business but also someone’s home.

    For this he is being crucified and – surprise, surprise – LFF has enthusiastically joined this witchhunt.

    I believe there are some B&Bs that describe themselves as gay B&Bs. I am not sure whether they are designed exclusively for gays or not, but I don’t see why they should not be if this is what they desire. I think Christian youth hostels should have the right to admit only Christians if that is what they desire. I think the black police association should be allowed to exist and bar whites. I find all of these things distasteful, but I think one has to tolerate them. The logic of the LFF worldview is that these things make me a bigot, which I think reflects badly on it.

  • http://www.shamik.co.uk Shamik Das

    Rory, a b&b is a business. It is illegal for a business in this country to discrimanate against someone on the grounds of religion, race or sexual orientation, and rightly so.

    Grayling gave a green light to bigots, the question now is whether David Cameron fires him, as was the case with the Tory/UUP candidate for South Antrim Adrian Watson, who was de-selected for making similar remarks.

    Whether Mr Cameron takes action or stays silent, as he’s done on Michal Kaminski’s anti-semitism, racism and homophobia, will prove once and for all just how much the Tories have (or haven’t) changed. The mask’s slipped.

  • http://twitter.com/seanics/status/11694649072 Sean Morton

    RT @leftfootfwd: Cam fails to say he's for "gay or straight". Unforgivable given concern over Graylings remarks on B&Bs http://bit.ly/b5QOVh

  • http://twitter.com/lgbtlabour/status/11697166775 LGBT Labour

    RT @leftfootfwd: Cam fails to say he's for "gay or straight". Unforgivable given concern over Graylings remarks on B&Bs http://bit.ly/b5QOVh

  • http://twitter.com/sambaconsam/status/11697423072 Sam Bacon

    RT @leftfootfwd: Cam fails to say he's for "gay or straight". Unforgivable given concern over Graylings remarks on B&Bs http://bit.ly/b5QOVh

  • http://twitter.com/tara_hewitt/status/11697498289 Tara Hewitt

    RT @leftfootfwd: Cam fails to say he's for "gay or straight". Unforgivable given concern over Graylings remarks on B&Bs http://bit.ly/b5QOVh

  • Rory

    So in that case do you think it is OK for some organisations that are not businesses to discriminate? Such as Christian youth hostels and the Black Police Association?

    I am genuinely interested to know.

  • http://twitter.com/lares09/status/11698286239 John Berry

    RT @tscholesfogg RT @psbook Cameron omits reference to gay community from speech http://is.gd/bgXm4 (via @leftfootfwd)

  • http://twitter.com/oxfordgirl/status/11698336334 oxfordgirl

    RT @lares09: RT @tscholesfogg RT @psbook Cameron omits reference to gay community from speech http://is.gd/bgXm4 (via @leftfootfwd)

  • Mr. Sensible

    The Conservatives and their candidates, particularly in the key marginals like the area where I live need to answer a big question:

    Do they back what Grayling said or do they not?

    And Rory, no one is obliging a B and B owner to provide that service; they do so of their own accord. They choose to provide the service and must live by the obligations of doing so.

    And I didn’t think the Black Police Association descriminated against non-black people.

  • http://twitter.com/imogenfm/status/11697385950 Imogen Flood-Murphy

    RT @leftfootfwd: Cam fails to say he's for "gay or straight". Unforgivable given concern over Graylings remarks on B&Bs http://bit.ly/b5QOVh

  • http://twitter.com/petebowler/status/11701023425 Pete Bowler

    RT @psbook: Cameron omits reference to gay community from speech http://is.gd/bgXm4 (via @leftfootfwd)

  • http://twitter.com/lgbtlabour/status/11702797745 LGBT Labour

    RT @ciphergoth: Cameron's speech for the cameras leaves out "gay or straight" http://j.mp/dwWjvg

  • http://twitter.com/lgbtlabour/status/11702907391 LGBT Labour

    RT @WillHeaven: Sharp spot. RT @leftfootfwd Cameron fails to say he's for "gay or straight"… http://bit.ly/b5QOVh

  • http://twitter.com/sspcampsie/status/11702915602 SSP Campsie

    RT @ciphergoth Cameron's speech for the cameras leaves out "gay or straight" http://short.to/2147k

  • http://twitter.com/sspcampsie/status/11702915602 SSP Campsie

    RT @ciphergoth Cameron's speech for the cameras leaves out "gay or straight" http://short.to/2147k

  • http://twitter.com/blogsoftheworld/status/11706257508 blogs of the world

    David Cameron fails to mention gay or straight – this despite briefing the line in advance… http://reduce.li/jkox2g #fails

  • http://twitter.com/deludeddonny/status/11707066848 Donovan Clarkson

    RT @ciphergoth: Cameron's speech for the cameras leaves out "gay or straight" http://j.mp/dwWjvg

  • Robert

    I think Grayling’s comments were none too clever towards the devoutly Christian, either, as I would imagine a very large proportion are not homophobic.

    Being a Christian does not imply being homophobic, does it?

  • Lord Palmerston

    But the Pink News poll wasn’t a fair one – the news article preceding the poll contained two negative comments about the Conservatives (and no positive or negative comments about any other parties) and the poll questions themselves contained anti-Tory questions before asking for voting intention.

    It’s not therefore surprising that the poll gave this result. But don’t expect it to be accurate.

  • http://twitter.com/michaelnastari/status/11711428938 Michael Nastari

    RT @LGBTLabour RT @ciphergoth: Cameron's speech for the cameras leaves out "gay or straight" http://j.mp/dwWjvg

  • http://bestblogs.labourhome.org/2010/04/06/cameron-fails-to-say-he%e2%80%99s-for-%e2%80%9cgay-or-straight%e2%80%9d/ Cameron fails to say he’s for “gay or straight” « The best Labour blogs

    [...] More… [...]

  • A J Scott

    I don’t think I’ve ever read such a staggering load of self-opinionated hogwash over an issue so staggeringly unimportant compared with the real issues of this GE. Obviously, someone has frightened the horses-hence the loads of horse manure.

  • Paul B

    He failed to mention gay or straight, because neither are ignored.

    Labour need to answer a big question, whats more important, the power of the state to impose its will via the law, or the right of the individual to conduct his or her business as sees fit. If Gays can have Gay only Bnb`s – why shouldn`t Christians have straight only Bnb ? Its your typical state powered fascist socialists at work again

  • Rob

    Intresting aside on the thing about Black groups with white members. My Gran re-married a Jamaican immigrant. The caribeen society to which they belonged admited peoples of all races and creeds but had a rule that offical posts had to be staffed by people of carribeen heritage. The society wanted to make my gran Treasurer so they declared her an Honoury Jamaican. :D

  • Rory

    Yes, that is an interesting aside, Rob. But unfortunately Mr Das does not seem to want to answer my questions.

  • M. DJUIDJE

    David Cameron had a great speech but was shy when talking about people of colour. I expected him to talk about promoting race equality in the work place, ending the term “ethnic background” so that “Britishness” has the same meaning for everyone. This is the change modern Britain need Today.

  • MAJOLY

    The real change I would like to hear from any political party is race equality in this country. “Britishness” should have the same meaning for everyone. This is what we need in modern Britain today.

  • MAJOLY

    In his speech, David Cameron failed to address the race equality issue. This is the change we need.

  • http://Geoff_Carrotte@yahoo.co.uk Fred Blogs

    Ignoring part of the “Great Ignored”. A bit of a false start for Dave.

  • Mark M

    Ahh, the Grayling story again. Always got to bring that up. His words were “if it’s a question of somebody who’s doing a B&B in their own home, that individual should have the right to decide who does and who doesn’t come into their own home”.

    Are those such controversial vews to hold? Would we expect a Jewish B&B owener to be welcoming of, say, a group of Muslims or vice versa? Remember, we’re talking about coming into a person’s home, that happens to be a B&B, not a hotel. Now would LFF be so critical of Grayling if the B&B owner in question had been a Muslim refusing two gay men?

    As for Cameron leaving out “gay or straight”, that’s clearly an error of memory. You’d have to be clinically insane, or perhaps Labour voter, to think otherwise.

  • lennylf

    Cameron ignores the “Great Ignored”
    Memory loss for a potential premiere who is still in his early 40s? Perhaps dementia is setting in early for Cameron ; or maybe he is an opportunist hypocrite , and has decided to follow the , “dont do what I say , do what I do ” philosophy ,and just ignore the gay society , just to support Chris Grayling’s comments.
    As for a Jewish B&B ignoring Muslim Customers ? Is the person who posted the suggestion not just a tide bit encouraging prejudice just to Support Cameron’s silence over his hand picked shadow cabinet minister Chris Grayling ?

  • scouser

    regarding the people who offended the gay couple, they would allow them to sleep in their home and did not throw them out, if i threw gordon brown out of the pub i run would i be in the wrong

  • James E Pennington

    I’m a LAbour member and a committed Christian and I am so upset by the way the Labour Party seems to undermine many Christian values at every opportunity. TO repeal the Waddington Amendment which would then make it illegal for a youth worker to tell his youth group about God’s biblically given view of the right framework for sexual relationships.. ie marriage.. This isn’t Labour.. it’s control freakery masquerading as the one thing it isn’t.. Liberalism.

    The outcry of horror and pressure from the gay lobby over a genuine concern over the rights of religious people v gay people.. you’d think Grayling had suggested slaughtering the firstborn or something!! PLease please please Labour party.. don’t make it impossible for me to support you. I love all people in Christ, allpeople.. but I have to be free to preach the gospel and live it.. In a choice between Labour and God, who d’ya think might win??

  • James E Pennington

    May i also reiterate Rory’s question about how you’dall feel if it were a muslim bnb that had not allowed a gay couple a double room? It does seem like there are double standards here, and for reasons I can’t fully understand.

  • http://www.leftfootforward.org/2010/04/look-left-the-week-in-fast-forward-09-04-10/ Look Left – The Week in Fast Forward | Left Foot Forward

    [...] to the announcement of the election on Tuesday, Mr Cameron had only said he was for “young or old, rich or poor, black or white” but not [...]

  • David Galea

    Adultery destroys lives and is immoral, so should we make that illegal too?

  • http://ratemytory.org.uk/2010/04/21/tribal-voters-show-tory-manifesto-pandering-to-core-support/ Tribal voters show Tory manifesto pandering to core support « Rate My Tory

    [...] the indifference of Tory voters towards equal gay rights might explain Cameron’s non-inclusion of homosexuals in his ‘Great Ignored’ speech, not to mention the party’s hideous record on the [...]