Tory attack video full of lies

The latest Conservative Party attack viral has been slammed by fact-checkers for a series of made up statistics on school discipline, quangos and job losses. Several Tory claims, in a video titled “What happens in 1 Minute of Labour” are seriously inaccurate and misleading – some by factors of nearly 400 per cent.

David-Cameron-George-Osborne-smirking School suspensions: Tory claim: “Four children are suspended from school every minute” – equates to 2.102 million a year. The truth: In 2007/08, there were 456,411 exclusions (permanent and fixed-term). Tory mark-up: 361 per cent.

Quangos: Tory claim: “Every minute the Government takes £964,612 from us in tax while unelected quangos cost the taxpayer £170,765″ – equivalent to £89.754 billion a year. The truth: In 2008/09, non-departmental public bodies cost £38.4 billion. Tory mark-up: 134 per cent.

In September, Left Foot Forward exposed more right-wing lies on quangos; the Daily Mail had claimed the figure was £170 billion, saying there had been “a seven-fold rise since Labour came to power”.

Employment: Tory claim: “Every minute two people lose their jobs” – equal to 1.051 million a year. The truth: A year ago, 29.2 million people were employed; the current figure is 28.8 million, a total of 406,000 job losses. Tory mark-up: 159 per cent.

Their figures on violent crimes, tax and CO2 emissions are, however, accurate – yet each raise questions of their own.

Violent crimes: The video’s crime stat tallies with the British Crime Survey – yet David Cameron and his shadow home secretary Chris Grayling have consistently spoken out against the BCS, preferring instead to look at police recorded crime. The BCS, though, appears to be good enough for their video.

Tax: The video says tax receipts will be £507 billion – yet fails to spell out which public services will be slashed under the Tories in their haste to cut this sum.

CO2 emissions: The video correctly says “915 tones of carbon dioxide are release into our atmosphere” – but with all three parties signed up to the Copenhagen emission-reduction plans, it is difficult to see how the Tories would reduce this faster than Labour, and in any case, Tory candidates placed “reducing Britain’s carbon footprint” 19th out of 19 in a list of priorities for an incoming Cameron government.

http://twitter.com/pastyface43/status/12938150944 kate

RT @leftfootfwd: Tory attack video full of lies: http://bit.ly/bJSNHN
http://twitter.com/farrimond/status/12938287491 Richard A. Farrimond

http://www.leftfootforward.org/2010/04/tory-attack-video-full-of-lies/
http://twitter.com/jesus_john/status/12939034474 John West

RT @leftfootfwd: Tory attack video full of lies: http://bit.ly/bJSNHN
http://twitter.com/uponnothing/status/12939170871 Kevin Arscott

RT @leftfootfwd: Tory attack video full of lies: http://bit.ly/bJSNHN
http://twitter.com/andy_s_64/status/12938056460 Andy Sutherland

RT @leftfootfwd: Tory attack video full of lies: http://bit.ly/bJSNHN
http://twitter.com/riprap007/status/12938274933 Nicholas Ripley

RT @leftfootfwd: Tory attack video full of lies: http://bit.ly/bJSNHN
http://twitter.com/wildejunkie/status/12938961861 Kate Elizabeth

RT @leftfootfwd: Tory attack video full of lies: http://bit.ly/bJSNHN
http://viva-freemania.blogspot.com Tom Freeman

And the other problem is that there are no comparisons – is 915 tonnes of CO2 a minute worse than it used to be?

Well, no: http://viva-freemania.blogspot.com/2010/03/green-budget-economys-carbon-efficiency.html
J

Or, as the fact-checkers you link to actually suggest:

“There are different ways of calculating the figures that would result in different conclusions.”

It is spin, pure and simple – a rival ‘truth’ to Labour’s own misinformation.

I have no data, but would suggest that Tory figures on job losses are probably – possibly? – based on actual jobs lost, rather than a simple subtraction of “currently employed” and “previously employed”.

E.g. if three people lose their job and one finds work elsewhere, your method suggests only two job losses. Whereas the reality is three.

Incidentally, I hope all politicians and spinners are sucked into a void (where they choke on their own intestines) and that nobody is elected.
http://bestblogs.labourhome.org/2010/04/27/tory-attack-video-full-of-lies/ Tory attack video full of lies « The best Labour blogs

[...] More… [...]
John A Fotheringham

Just in fairness (to the statistics, not to those making claims or counter-claims)

4/minute for all the minutes the schools are OPEN works out on the back of my envelope as 430,000 (admittedly I’m not very familiar with the length of a school day).

I think you can jsutify this stat if you define carefully what constitutes a “minute” in this context. Every minute of every day, or every minute the schools are open. Of course people rarely define precisely what they mean by a statistic, hence their use to mislead.

It just goes to show how people can warp perfectly meaningful stats to their own ends…
http://twitter.com/bisyss/status/12949472437 Max Leach

What happens in 1 Minute of Complete Bullshit: http://digs.by/bKq61l
http://twitter.com/misstjd/status/13001079295 MissTJD

RT @leftfootfwd: Tory attack video full of lies: http://bit.ly/bJSNHN
http://twitter.com/matt_zarbcousin/status/13036288879 Matthew Zarb-Cousin

RT @mattlodder: Tory attack video full of lies: The latest Conservative Party attack viral has been slammed by fact-checkers for a… http://bit.ly/97I6Hx
http://twitter.com/mattlodder/status/13036119612 Matt Lodder

Tory attack video full of lies: The latest Conservative Party attack viral has been slammed by fact-checkers for a… http://bit.ly/97I6Hx
http://twitter.com/aledwg/status/13052905992 Aled Wyn

RT @mattlodder: Tory attack video full of lies: The latest Conservative Party attack viral has been slammed by fact-checkers for a… http://bit.ly/97I6Hx
http://none Honestman

So why believe the Tories, Why Not I ask, After listening To Brown lie to me on every important matter from Iraq, The troops Budget cut, The Chilcott Enquiry, Our Vote on Europe, What happened to my democratic vote, the one my day went to war for. Even yesterday, Brown stood on Mrs, Duffy’s driveway and lied to all of us.