505 views
Public Services for All > Published by Liam R Thompson, October 11th 2010 at 12:27 pm

Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron?

Print Friendly

Senior Liberal Democrats are facing significant resistance from their political opponents and no doubt their own activists, over the less than graceful U-turn over student tuition fees.

Nick-Clegg-tuition-fees-pledgeIt is expected that Lord Browne will recommend a dramatic increase in student tuition fees, raising the cap to as much as £7,000 or scrapping it all together, in addition to raising the interest on student loan repayments – despite the Lib Dems pledging at the general election to remove fees altogether.

Some embarrassing photographs of Lib Dem cabinet members (never mind every single Lib Dem MP and 500 PPCs) signing the NUS pledge opposing tuition fees are likely to make appearances in the press over the coming days. The Lib Dem MPs pledged:

“…to vote against any increase in fees in the next parliament and to pressure the government to introduce a fairer alternative.”

Among those MPs is Bristol West Lib Dem Stephen Williams; upon signing the NUS pledge as shadow minister for universities and skills, he said that the Lib Dem parliamentary party would vote against any increase in tuition fees and “fight any attempt to raise the cap”.

During May’s election campaign, Lib PPCs pledged that the party would abolish tuition completely. They even boasted that their manifesto policy had been fully costed, and that Lib Dems would start scrapping fees immediately, starting with final-year fees, working down until “all university education is free”.

The same election leaflets goaded Labour’s unpopularity over top-up fees and the Conservative’s plans to “double tuition fees”.

If it was fully costed then, why merely months later is it completely unaffordable? After losing the conference vote on free schools, and with some backbenchers already promising to abstain from the vote on the issue – what will the grass-roots of the party think of this latest betrayal?

  • http://twitter.com/glspen/status/27025025205 glspen

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/reeceemmitt/status/27025033659 Reece Emmitt

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/elganjohn/status/27025139300 elgan

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/mariocreatura/status/27025145924 Mario Creatura

    Not Cameron… Lord Browne: RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/kristoferkeane/status/27025161407 Kristofer Keane

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/politicsteacher/status/27025544233 Nicola Morgan

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/doctorpete/status/27025761441 Pete

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/susan_nash/status/27025814803 Susan Nash

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/soozyshoes/status/27026148417 Susan Asquith

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/wolfpupjon/status/27026249213 Jon (Bambi) Page

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/antipathy/status/27026303556 Simon

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/peteonthea419/status/27026315811 Pete Berry

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/joshuwahwah/status/27026400395 Joshuwahwah

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/bvulliamy/status/27026441509 Ben Vulliamy

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/michaellammiman/status/27026502267 Mike Lammiman

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/todjsullivan/status/27026796872 Tod Sullivan

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/yoursu/status/27027176292 Your Students Union

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/westernshores/status/27027475793 Pen

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/maroqui/status/27027518699 Youssef

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/barry_gardiner/status/27027699818 Barry Gardiner MP

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/geedee86/status/27028244368 Gareth Douce

    RT @TodJSullivan: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • Chris

    In defence of taking away people’s public services, Nick Clegg keeps wheeling out some variation of “Look, we have to do this, we have to get rid of this budget deficit to avoid passing debt on to our children, which is immoral”. The best way of doing this, apparently, is massively raising debt on children.

    We already knew Clegg’s word was worthless (he’s a politician) that’s why we made him sign the pledge, and made the text of the pledge so clear. Here is the full res photo – http://www.libdemvoice.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/Huppert-and-Clegg.jpg – standing in the world’s best university that he and the Lib Dem MP there attended for free.

    “How about Cambridge?”
    “Well, despite going to a crap comprehensive, I’m surely clever enough to get in, but I can’t afford it. What’s the best place to study Maths within my price range?”

    “Hi UCAS adviser, I got ABB and I love Geography but I want to go somewhere with a good music scene, which uni choices should I put?”
    “Well, first things first – how rich are your parents?”

    This is the Britain you have created, Nick Clegg, you lying piece of shit.

  • Richard

    And how can Vince Cable possibly abstain from voting on his own policy and have any credibilty left? He’ll be an even bigger laughing staock.

  • Chris
  • http://twitter.com/owenhughes86/status/27030809473 Owen Hughes

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • Chris

    I particularly like the bit when Clegg says “I believe its time promises were kept.”

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dYMN7l_wo5U

  • http://twitter.com/robw91/status/27033190154 Robert Williamson

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/teignroy/status/27033816420 roy

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/marcusaroberts/status/27033859649 Marcus A. Roberts

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • Evidence based.

    Fair enough, I guess this is what being in coalition means though. Though If Labour try to make capital out of this it would be ragingly hypocritical.

  • John Moss

    Strictly speaking, voting to scrap the cap on fees is not voting for an increase and if the package can be seen as “fairer”, then what’s the problem.

    Let’s face it, either many fewer people got to University and study a vastly reduced range of subjects, or students have to pay from their future earnings.

    Personally, I have always argued for 100% tax relief on repayments (not interest) in the same way we give companies tax relief on their investment in machinery. Couple that with a grant to students from the poorest households and a complete market in courses and I suspect we will have more diversity, more choice and cheaper HE to boot!

  • http://twitter.com/tess1959/status/27034071585 Teresa

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/wdjstraw/status/27034150586 Will Straw

    @bristolwestpaul @bristolred @gusbaker Hope you saw our piece on LD fees pledge feat @swilliamsmp http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/petekc/status/27035332723 Pete Kennedy-Chapman

    RT @wdjstraw: @bristolwestpaul @bristolred @gusbaker Hope you saw our piece on LD fees pledge feat @swilliamsmp http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/bristolwestpaul/status/27037563341 Paul Smith Bristol

    RT @wdjstraw: @bristolwestpaul @bristolred @gusbaker Hope you saw our piece on LD fees pledge feat @swilliamsmp http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/frasernesbitt/status/27038392093 Fraser Nesbitt

    See @wdjstraw and Left Foot Forward are being pretty economical with the truth in this article http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • Chris

    @John Moss

    LOL, I’d like to see Clegg sell that to a crowd of angry students – “I didn’t vote to increase fees, just remove the cap.”.

    We only have to look at the American system to see how crap our system will become if we allow a market in universities.

  • http://twitter.com/bristolred/status/27039213842 Darren Lewis

    RT @wdjstraw: @bristolwestpaul @bristolred @gusbaker Hope you saw our piece on LD fees pledge feat @swilliamsmp http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/becc1_boo/status/27041563741 Becci

    Dear Lib Dem voters, Believe me now?! Kind Regards. http://bit.ly/aTR5ay #watereddowntories

  • http://twitter.com/cllrcowley/status/27042622515 James Cowley

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • jeff marks

    what’s wrong with getting a loan and people paying for their own education post 18 years old? why should hard working plumbers pay for middle-class students to spend 3 years boozing? where’s the fairness in that?

    graduates make so much more over their lifetimes it’s fair they pay for the education.

  • Kris

    You’r being jolly unfair on these nice lib dems. They wrote their manifesto in the full expectation that they would not be in government and could say what ever they liked to win votes.

  • http://twitter.com/big_jen/status/27046270921 Jennie Cross

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • http://twitter.com/rajeevtrikha/status/27047910368 Rajeev Trikha

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • jeff marks

    lib dems have a problem. they are a liberal party that has been invaded by a fifth column of socialists from Labour. it is a classic black operation. i would have called myself and voted liberal before the party was infected by these Marxist vermin

  • http://politicalreboot.blogspot.com/ Eddy Anderson

    Fantastic post Left Foot Forward. Is it time to make bets on the Coalition’s longevity?

    http://politicalreboot.blogspot.com/2010/10/nick-clegg-compromise-or-surrender.html

  • Chris

    @jeff marks

    Because when the plumber has a heart attack the middle-class students who went to university to train as doctors, nurses, pharmacists, etc will treat him.

  • http://twitter.com/andrewroche/status/27053324802 Andrew Roche

    Just read: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://dlvr.it/6v21C

  • Chris

    @jeff marks

    Oh and when the plumber has kids, the working, middle and upper-class kids who went to university will teach his kids how to read, write, etc and hopefully inspire them to better themselves through education so they don’t have to live in human shit for a living.

    Not forgetting the working, middle and upper-class students who through university education go on to earn lots of money so they can pay plumbers to come round and clear the soil stack rather than doing it themselves. Or fit the new kitchen or the new boiler.

  • The plumber

    “Oh what a tangle web we weave; when we first practise to deceive” recite 3000 times by the 20th October please Nick Clegg.

  • http://twitter.com/lwxmb19/status/27060785258 Cllr Muhammed Butt

    The picture to haunt nick clegg for a long time. Lib dems have a history of going back on their word. http://bit.ly/bcarL9

  • http://twitter.com/joshuwahwah/status/27061482804 Joshuwahwah

    Will Nick Clegg honour his pledge, or will he bow down to his Tory paymasters? http://bit.ly/bcarL9

  • http://twitter.com/davidianskinner/status/27063765076 David Skinner

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/bcarL9

  • http://twitter.com/goldsmithsucu/status/27067457183 Goldsmiths UCU

    RT @leftfootfwd: Every Lib Dem MP signed NUS pledge – will they all now cave in to Cameron? http://bit.ly/aTR5ay

  • Diane

    Not defending them, but this is how Coalitions tend to go. A left-wing party in Europe went in with the right-wing party and one of their “compromises” was on banning the niqab.

    They’ll probably just use the wording of the pledge against any critics – all they have to say is Vince’s policy is a “fairer alternative”.

  • Mr. Sensible

    ‘Evidence Based’ et al, there’s compromise, and there’s compromise.

    The Lib Dems said a lot of things during the election, didn’t they.

  • jeff marks

    the lib dem manifesto can’t be taken at face value. they said a lot of stuff and never thought they’d be in power. they promised the earth and sky but in reality just wanted to maximise their seats. give them a break. they’re in coalition with a real party. they have to be allowed to re-evaluate their policies. anybody know what sarah teather is up to? any back stabbing?

  • http://www.betternation.org/2010/10/unbelievably-graduates-already-pay-tax/ Unbelievably, graduates already pay tax « Better Nation

    [...] into the 2010 UK General Election having given the NUS pledges not to raise fees – who have damning pictures ready should they sell out. I can see why NUS felt it necessary to extract this pledge, given their [...]

  • ColinW

    The Torture & Rendition Party had a manifesto commitment to NOT introduce tuition fees. Then they introduced them in government, with a big majority & a buoyant economy.

    And they took us into an illegal war too.

  • http://blogs.channel4.com/gary-gibbon-on-politics/lib-dem-tuition-fees-rebellion-or-not/13897 Gary Gibbon on Politics – Lib Dem tuition fees rebellion – or not

    [...] he signed the infamous NUS pledge to fight any rise in tuition fees in the election campaign, Nick Clegg actually tried to dump the [...]

  • http://www.leftfootforward.org/2010/10/lord-browne-higher-education-review-scottish-reaction/ SNP education secretary rejects Browne’s findings for Scotland | Left Foot Forward

    [...] the publication of Lord Browne’s review into higher education funding has proved controversial in England, in Scotland the mood music from the SNP Government has been positively frosty. [...]

  • http://www.leftfootforward.org/2010/10/uniting-the-east-end-a-call-to-action-in-tower-hamlets/ Uniting the East End: A call to action in Tower Hamlets | Left Foot Forward

    [...] with trepidation for the results of the Comprehensive Spending Review, while marvelling at the twists and turns of Lib Dem MPs as they attempt to crawl out from the tatters of their higher education policy, [...]

  • Mr. Sensible

    Geoff I’m not sure they’ll keep those seats.

    The fact is that Lib Dem voters did not vote for this.

  • http://trialbyjeory.wordpress.com/2010/10/15/rushanara-alis-call-for-action/ Rushanara Ali’s call for action « Trial By Jeory

    [...] with trepidation for the results of the Comprehensive Spending Review, while marvelling at the twists and turns of Lib Dem MPs as they attempt to crawl out from the tatters of their higher education policy, [...]

  • Robert

    Then again it was labour that brought in those charges for god sake your blaming a group who were desperate to get into power, labour were in power.

  • http://www.leftfootforward.org/2010/10/another-lib-dem-u-turn-this-time-they-vote-down-votes-at-16/ Another Lib Dem u-turn – this time they vote down votes at 16 | Left Foot Forward

    [...] latest u-turn follows on from the furore over tuition fees last week, with the Lib Dems reigning on their direct pledge to the NUS that they would fight any [...]

  • StevieG

    Middle-class high-earners already pay more. By earning more they pay much more in tax. Building in even more inequity is not the answer.

  • http://sgmpolitics.wordpress.com/2010/10/19/lib-dem-tuition-fee-u-turn/ Lib Dem tuition fee u-turn « sgmpolitics

    [...] the way for huge increases in fees. The Guardian reports a major rebellion in the offing over this major policy u-turn. Leave a [...]

  • http://www.leftfootforward.org/2010/10/nick-clegg-digging-himself-into-a-hole-over-university-funding/ Clegg “digging himself into a hole” over university funding | Left Foot Forward

    [...] Browne review – this despite him, along with every other Lib Dem general election candidate, pledging “to vote against any increase in fees in the next parliament and to pressure the government [...]

  • http://www.leftfootforward.org/2010/10/browne-review-to-cost-taxpayer-more/ Ideological Browne review will end up costing taxpayer more | Left Foot Forward

    [...] and Vince Cable insisting tuition fee increases will be capped – Clegg even suggesting his u-turn over his pledge to scrap fees “had to be done due to the financial situation the country was [...]

  • http://www.leftfootforward.org/2010/10/look-left-29-10-10/ Look Left – Opposition grows to coalition’s unfair housing benefit cuts | Left Foot Forward

    [...] they’re running scared, unable and unwilling to look students in the eye and explain their u-turn. Nick Clegg is due to visit Oxford on Wednesday, November 17th – the question is, will he [...]

  • http://twitter.com/thejaymo/status/2317328544960512 Jay Springett

    @cubedweller Things like this damage British politics, makes me question their trustworthiness and damages the 'Brand' http://bit.ly/cVL4ac

  • http://www.leftfootforward.org/2010/12/student-protest-in-age-of-contempt/ Student protest in the age of contempt | Left Foot Forward

    [...] this, though, in saying the coalition agreement means more than the NUS pledge, Vince Cable and his party colleagues are effectively telling us that politicians believe the [...]

  • http://www.leftfootforward.org/2010/12/68pc-of-lib-dem-general-election-voters-think-fees-u-turn-is-wrong/ Two-thirds of Lib Dem general election voters against fees u-turn | Left Foot Forward

    [...] cent of those who voted Liberal Democrat in May say it is wrong for the party to break its election pledge to “vote against any increase in fees in the next parliament and to pressure the government [...]

  • http://ealingrose.com/2011/05/04/why-it-is-yes-for-me-on-av-and-no-to-any-more-referendums/ Why it is yes for me on AV (and no to any more referendums!) « The Ealing Rose

    [...] main reason for the sense of resentment over the Liberal democrats behaviour in abandoning many promises they claimed to hold dear was because of Clegg’s absurd refusal to talk about who he would deal with or what he would [...]

  • http://twitter.com/hushbone/status/149187930110435328 Hush Bone

    http://t.co/esMvuq5k #LieoftheYear #Clegg's promise to vote down tuition fees has to be the worst.