Cameron, Clarke, Dorries, Willetts… The Tories keep screwing up on gender equality

Now the dust has settled on Ken Clarke’s 36 hours in ministerial purgatory – in constant political pain, but not understanding the cause or the cure – a question arises: Why is it that Conservatives have such a problem with gender equality and women’s issues in general?

David-Cameron The last two months alone have featured a litany of misteps by Tories:

1) David Willetts: “Feminism trumps egalitarianism”

One may think that declining social mobility in the United Kingdom since the early 1980s may be down to governments and/or structural changes in the economy and society. After all, many Conservatives herald Margaret Thatcher as the woman who changed Britain for ever and irrevocably – the foremost political and cultural figure of our age.

But no. according to Willetts, 18 years of Conservative government, and 11 years of New Labour that accepted the Thatcherite settlement weren’t the cause – it was those pesky feminists.

There is an academic debate here – and Declan Gaffney’s analyis on Left Foot Forward showed, crudely put, that women’s entry into the workforce has a racheting effect. Those countries that are fairly equal become more equal, and those countries which are fairly unequal become more unequal.

But Willetts’s comments were dutifully reported in the right-wing press as blaming the problems of the male working-class at the hands of women and more particularly feminists.

The UK media uses quite a bit of newsprint making women feel guilty for going to work, and Willetts gave them even more ammunition.

2) David Cameron: ‘Calm down dear’

Yes, ‘calm down dear’ is a fairly tiresome catchphrase from an advert on TV. But it is also incredibly patronising. What Cameron didn’t appreciate when he tried to belittle Angela Eagle at Prime Minister’s Questions is how thousands of women are patronised regularly at their workplace and in wider life.

It betrayed a blind spot on the reality of other people’s lives. According to a recent Ipsos-Mori poll (pdf) around two-fifth of women have experienced sexist behavior, including “being whistled at, having sexist comments directed towards you, being touched innappropriately or being discriminated because of your gender”.

3) Nadine Dorries: “Girls – just say no”

Then we have Nadine Dorries’s ten-minute rule bill that calls upon sex education teachers to tell girls aged 13 to 16 that they should say no to sex.

The exact text says:

“That leave be given to bring in a Bill to require schools to provide certain additional sex education to girls aged between 13 and 16; to provide that such education must include information and advice on the benefits of abstinence from sexual activity; and for connected purposes.”

The bill may be accused of ignorance – advising teenagers that they should remain abstinent until they feel emotionally ready for sex is already part of good sex education practice. But worse, there is no part of the bill that instructs teachers to reach boys to say no, or to not pressurise girls into sex. The implication being that when it comes to unwanted pregnancies, its the girls who are soley to blame, and boys are responsibility-free.

This is before we get to Dorries’ assertion that if more girls said no, this would lead to less sexual abuse. Sixty-seven MPs in total voted for the bill – 62 Conservaties, two Labour, two Democratic Unionist and one Liberal Democrat.

4) Ken Clarke: “Classic rape”

What Ken Clarke said and didn’t say has been subject to more analysis than the average Shakespearean speech in the last week. However, the two main charges seem to be that he spoke about it in too light a tone, and that rape where the victim and perpetrator knew each other, or which followed a date, would be a mitigating factor.

After decades of campaigners trying to push for a cultural change in society to etablish date rape as serious as stranger rape, it appeared as if the justice secretary didn’t consider it – in his words – ‘classic rape’.

In the Tories’ defence, the 2010 intake did start to address the gender inbalance among their ranks with plenty of talented examples. However, there is a wider concern that the Government cuts will affect women disproprotionatelly. So much so that cross-party support for a select committee dedicated to women’s issues seems to be growing.

Although each of the episodes can be explained away by giving the benefit of the doubt, a simpler reading would be that David Cameron’s ‘detoxification’ project – so successful on issues like race, sexuality and the environment – took a pass on gender issues.

http://twitter.com/redbuttongirl/status/72293285565169664 Carmen

RT @leftfootfwd: Cameron, Clarke, Dorries, Willetts… The Tories still don't get gender equality: http://bit.ly/modQgQ by @DanielElton
http://twitter.com/kindjourneys/status/72293327957008384 Elly M

RT @leftfootfwd: Cameron, Clarke, Dorries, Willetts… The Tories still don't get gender equality: http://bit.ly/modQgQ by @DanielElton
http://twitter.com/martalucysummer/status/72293658300395520 Marta Owczarek

RT @leftfootfwd: Cameron, Clarke, Dorries, Willetts… The Tories still don't get gender equality: http://bit.ly/modQgQ by @DanielElton
http://twitter.com/snudger12/status/72293765510995968 Michael Thompson

RT @leftfootfwd: Cameron, Clarke, Dorries, Willetts… The Tories still don't get gender equality: http://bit.ly/modQgQ by @DanielElton
http://twitter.com/virginiamoffatt/status/72294858169131009 Virginia Moffatt

RT @leftfootfwd: Cameron, Clarke, Dorries, Willetts… The Tories still don't get gender equality: http://bit.ly/modQgQ by @DanielElton
http://twitter.com/dustsister/status/72296850513870848 Dusty

RT @leftfootfwd: Cameron, Clarke, Dorries, Willetts… The Tories still don't get gender equality: http://bit.ly/modQgQ by @DanielElton
http://twitter.com/neurophysman/status/72297839878864896 Stuart Smith

RT @TheRightArticle: Cameron, Clarke, Dorries, Willetts… The Tories keep screwing up on gender equality http://bit.ly/jVdANY
Ed’s Talking Balls

Daniel Elton,

Calm down, dear.
http://twitter.com/emilymarydavis/status/72327988645085184 Emily Davis

RT @leftfootfwd: Cameron, Clarke, Dorries, Willetts… The Tories still don't get gender equality: http://bit.ly/modQgQ by @DanielElton
http://twitter.com/quarridors/status/72356027760254976 Quarries & Corridors

Cameron, Clarke, Dorries, Willetts… The Tories still don't get gender equality: http://bit.ly/modQgQ by @DanielElton
http://twitter.com/janerthered/status/72368061751103488 Patricia Jane Mowat

Cameron, Clarke, Dorries, Willetts… The Tories still don't get gender equality: http://bit.ly/modQgQ by @DanielElton
http://jennie-kermode.blogspot.com/ Jennie Kermode

Don’t forget former MSP Bill Aitken and his comments on a particular Glasgow rape; or the Payam Tamiz, the councillor and PPC removed for calling women ‘sluts’ in his blog. And then, of course, there was Rogar Helmer MEP with his comments on rape today. The COnservatives have an endemic problem on these issues which they need to tackle with training at a local party level, not just sticking-plaster apologies and excuses after problems occur.
Tories Hate Women

Tories hate women, and here is the evidence: twice as many women work in the public sector as men, therefore the cuts to community services will affect more women. It has an extra affect against women as women will be losing jobs and services and in many cases both.

The question is of course, why do the Tories hate women? They clearly feel superior to women but that does not justify their hatred. Perhaps they harbour a hatred not just for women per se but for anybody they believe is below their class.

And so their thinking must follow, as Ken Clarke demonstrated, they believe that it does not really matter if someone who is not of their class is raped, or mugged or murdered as that person is not worth as much as people of their higher caste are.

In short, they think they are better than us. And yet we pay their wages. It is the same old Tory thinking, it just doesn’t make any sense at all. The Tories are like vampires who take delight in taking advantage of the vulnerable and those who cannot defend themselves.

They are vultures and have not changed at all. Indeed, with the women haters David Cameron and George Osborne in charge the Tories are going backwards.
http://universeandeverything.wordpress.com/2011/05/22/identity-gender-and-the-seach-for-a-hammer-pt-1-and-2/ Identity, Gender, and the seach for a hammer Pt. 1 and 2. | universe and everything

[...] no higher than anyone else’s and if most people can control themselves so can you. And yes, rape is rape, no matter what. ) Sexism is all around us and is a battle you fight every [...]
http://twitter.com/jhsmith/status/72380743149559808 Jen Smith

RT @leftfootfwd: Cameron, Clarke, Dorries, Willetts… The Tories keep screwing up on gender equality http://t.co/ne1gpNE
http://twitter.com/shellyasquith/status/72410232680218624 Shelly Asquith

RT @leftfootfwd: Cameron, Clarke, Dorries, Willetts… The Tories keep screwing up on gender equality http://t.co/EW6uyEN
http://twitter.com/tattymoustache/status/72410841437306880 Jade Constable

RT @leftfootfwd: Cameron, Clarke, Dorries, Willetts… The Tories keep screwing up on gender equality http://t.co/EW6uyEN
http://twitter.com/sianberry/status/72413284912996352 sianberry

Oh how depressing RT @leftfootfwd: Cameron, Clarke, Dorries, Willetts… The Tories keep screwing up on gender equality http://t.co/sFpJA3h
http://twitter.com/rotster/status/72414727304781824 Rob Clarke

Oh how depressing RT @leftfootfwd: Cameron, Clarke, Dorries, Willetts… The Tories keep screwing up on gender equality http://t.co/sFpJA3h
http://www.twitter.com/ShellyAsquith Shelly

I was going to tell you to add Frank Field to that list after his comments yesterday, then I remembered…
http://twitter.com/hali__/status/72429598931034113 Hali

Just in case you forgot how awful the Conservative Party is when it comes to sexism: http://bit.ly/modQgQ
http://twitter.com/dimitri1906/status/72430723776258048 Joshua Goodman

Just in case you forgot how awful the Conservative Party is when it comes to sexism: http://bit.ly/modQgQ
Mr. Sensible

Couldn’t agree more Daniel.

Given all that, is it not therefore correct to say that it is not just the Liberal Democrats who need to assert themselves more within the Coalition, but also the equalities office?
http://twitter.com/myinfamy/status/72720510152220672 Daniel Pitt

Cameron, Clarke, Dorries, Willetts… The Tories still don't get gender equality: http://bit.ly/modQgQ #ConDemNation
http://twitter.com/bennmillslight/status/72810921105436672 Bennett Mills

Cameron, Clarke, Dorries, Willetts… The Tories keep screwing up … http://bit.ly/lDrzDo
http://www.leftfootforward.org/2011/05/where-are-all-the-women/ Where are all the women? | Left Foot Forward

[...] regressive views about women still appear to be prevalent among Tories - recent comments by Nadine Dorries and Roger Helmer MEP are but two [...]
http://twitter.com/theicnetwork/status/74035268843356160 Interconnect Network

Left Foot Forward reckons the Tories keep 'screwing up' on gender equality. What do you think? http://tinyurl.com/3odcsgm
http://tintrent.blogspot.com Tim

I think it may be worth noticing that Nadine Dorries appears to be a woman. Perhaps she’s doing it to be ironic.
http://www.leftfootforward.org/2011/09/chris-huhne-tea-party-tories-philip-davies-dominic-raab-sajid-javid-nadine-dorries-douglas-carswell/ Huhne attacks “Tea Party Tories” – who on Earth does he mean?! | Left Foot Forward

[...] too much while on DLA, has admitted her blog is 70% fiction, and most notoriously called for abstinence-based sex education for young [...]
http://www.leftfootforward.org/2011/10/david-cameron-maternity-leave-women-voters-sexism-problem/ Two weeks after ‘fixing’ it, Cameron creates a new “women problem” | Left Foot Forward

[...] Cameron, Clarke, Dorries, Willetts… The Tories keep screwing up on gender equality – Daniel Elton, May 22nd [...]
http://www.leftfootforward.org/2011/10/the-lack-of-women-in-westminster-has-gone-on-for-too-long/ The lack of women in Westminster has gone on for too long | Left Foot Forward

[...] Where are all the women? – Ronit Wolfson, May 24th [...]
http://twitter.com/macinpoole/status/139329342701436929 malcolm

problems for Tories with women #PMQs : http://t.co/IVNTfG5A