Hillsborough ‘Thatcher briefings’ will bring truth a step closer
Twenty two years after 96 football fans were crushed to death in Sheffield Wednesday’s Hillsborough football stadium, the long and tenacious campaign to establish the truth of what happened on that fateful day looks set to come an important step closer.

The Cabinet Office will release key documents which were used to brief prime pinister Margaret Thatcher immediately after the event. Many believe these will confirm that the police offered a partial version of events in order to avoid their own culpability for the tragedy. Altogether, 766 people were injured on April on April 15th 1989. A judicial inquiry later blamed the police for their failure to manage the crowd properly.
Many of the 96 fans who died were under 30; a third were teenagers, while the youngest was just 10 years-old.
As Rogan Taylor, director of the Football Industry Group at the University of Liverpool (and an attendee at the game), points out in The Independent:
“Lord Justice Taylor’s Inquiry [into the tragedy] principally blamed the police. But the Hillsborough families have never received justice; they never accepted the ‘accidental death’ verdicts and the fact that so much evidence of incompetence before and after the disaster was not heard in court.
“They have fought for over two decades to unearth the real ‘truth’, supported by almost everyone in Liverpool and many outside too.”
Fast forward 22 years. The Information Commissioner, Christopher Graham, ruled last month that the Cabinet Office should release “briefings and other information provided to the prime minister in April 1989 relating to the Hillsborough disaster” following a Freedom of Information request by BBC journalists.
David Conn in The Guardian offers an excellent summation of why the information set to be revealed is so important and eagerly anticipated:
“The families have always pointed to Thatcher’s visit to Hillsborough the day after the disaster, 16th April 1989, when she was briefed by the then South Yorkshire police chief constable, Peter Wright. The police case, to Lord Justice Taylor’s subsequent inquiry and the coroner’s inquest, was that the disaster was caused by misbehaving and drunk Liverpool fans, many arriving late and without tickets.
“Taylor rejected that completely, laid the blame firmly on police mismanagement of the crowd – together with the unsafe ground, which was not properly overseen by the council – and he criticised the police for presenting the story of fans’ misbehaviour. Despite that, Thatcher’s press secretary, Bernard Ingham, who went with her to Hillsborough, maintained a view that the disaster was caused by, as he put it, ‘a tanked up mob’ of Liverpool fans.
“That led families, survivors of the disaster and supporters to believe that he and Thatcher must have been told that version of events during their visit, and so would have been more sympathetic to the police’s conduct of its case through the legal processes which followed.”
This Information Commissioner’s fairly straightforward instruction to disclose the files has, however, run into a bureaucratic web.
The government has challenged the ruling on the technicality that the documentation should first be given to the Hillsborough Independent Panel – the body set-up in 2009 to wade through the voluminous raft of documents about the tragedy kept by a variety of statutory bodies in order to pull together an authoritative account of what happened.
The panel, chaired by the Bishop of Liverpool, James Jones, is reviewing hundreds of thousands of documents and, after some initial confusion, now looks set to oversee the publication of the Thatcher briefings. Although not the immediate release that the Information Commissioner has sanctioned, this course of action is acceptable to the Hillsborough Family Support Group
Chair Margaret Aspinall said:
“We want full disclosure of all documents, with no redactions…
“But although we are cautious given our experience over 22 years, we do trust the panel and maintain that the papers be released to the panel first, so they can be put into context, and then shown to the families, before then being released to the wider public.”
As with the families of those killed on Bloody Sunday, it is vital that those who have been given little or no reason to take the word of the authorities at face value, feel that what they receive is a full and final version of the truth.
The legacy of the Hillsborough tragedy is not confined to the worlds of sport or even the city of Liverpool.
The long and patient campaign for the truth waged by the families of the bereaved and injured is an inspirational tale of ordinary people holding public bodies accountable for their lethal failures; an e-petition calling for the release of the information attracted 125,000 signatures and looks set to trigger a parliamentary debate. This latest important victory for the families’ campaign brings the prospect of understanding a key aspect of that dreadful day an important step closer.
As Kenny Dalglish, Liverpool Football Club’s current manager (and their manager 22 years ago), put it:
“Everything is looking positive for the families and everybody, irrespective of what team they support, has made a massive contribution towards the success they are having at the moment.
“Long may it continue because it was Liverpool, but it could have been any football club and I think people respect that.”
-
http://twitter.com/shamikdas/status/106774981878358018 Shamik Das
-
http://twitter.com/politicalplanet/status/106777084273229826 Political Planet
-
http://twitter.com/mylesr2011/status/106777450318532608 myles rhinds
-
http://twitter.com/juliadesigns/status/106777804401680385 Julia Ault
-
http://twitter.com/mrsj0402/status/106789476721897472 lottiej81
-
http://twitter.com/theno1gaz/status/106789833015439361 Gary Johnson
-
http://twitter.com/chrisbx515/status/106797409316773889 chris paling
-
http://twitter.com/jblresearch/status/106806232588881921 John Lever
-
http://twitter.com/ukgooglenews/status/106809990291013634 Stuart
-
http://twitter.com/labour52rose/status/106811037856186368 Alex Braithwaite
-
http://twitter.com/lilminxv/status/106814652561899520 VeeBee
-
http://twitter.com/monsrobin/status/106826365910786048 Ben Mitchell
-
http://twitter.com/lutheblue/status/106833012926324736 Lucy Ashton
-
http://twitter.com/robjbsheff/status/106837836476588032 Rob from Hillsbro’
-
http://Workingonit... Ben Mitchell
-
http://twitter.com/alistairhudson/status/106849671003127808 Alistair Hudson
-
Mr. Sensible
-
Kevin
-
http://twitter.com/popsider/status/106856677357264896 Jonathan Rodgers
-
Ed’s Talking Balls
-
http://twitter.com/alistairhudson/status/106864491786014720 Alistair Hudson
-
http://twitter.com/alistairhudson/status/106867684007874561 Alistair Hudson
-
http://twitter.com/alistairhudson/status/106867840933568512 Alistair Hudson
-
http://twitter.com/sheffieldcityuk/status/106888957668753408 The Steel City
-
http://twitter.com/sheffieldcityuk/status/106903312502239232 The Steel City
-
Ben Mitchell
-
http://jiveblogger.com/2011/08/disaster-families-welcome-ruling-the-star/ Disaster families welcome ruling – The Star | Jiveblogger.com
-
Garfield Jones
-
Mr. Sensible
-
http://twitter.com/sir_k_dalglish/status/107154981458685952 Sir Kenny Dalglish
-
http://twitter.com/steverotherammp/status/107157187566116864 Steve Rotheram
-
http://twitter.com/merseynorthbm/status/107157507855757314 William Shortall
-
http://twitter.com/redfanaticlfc/status/107158214105251841 RedFanaticLFC
-
http://twitter.com/speyejoe/status/107158488584687616 Joe Halewood
-
http://twitter.com/mosesbanner/status/107158865715539968 Trebor!
-
http://twitter.com/rd13sports/status/107160825235636224 Russell Davies
-
http://twitter.com/lfcnextgamenews/status/107161049261817857 Next Match News ✔
-
http://twitter.com/tel11dog/status/107164103897919488 Terry Dunning
-
http://twitter.com/3007marie/status/107164307820789760 Marie Weir
-
http://twitter.com/ciaranmeagher/status/107164334198763521 Ciaran Meagher
-
http://twitter.com/mpalms81/status/107164473340596224 Mark Palmer
-
http://twitter.com/flweber77/status/107164474213019648 Fred We´beer
-
http://twitter.com/daddybigbum/status/107164572099690497 andy 1977
-
http://twitter.com/peterhypnotic/status/107164763502551041 Peter Gacheru
-
http://twitter.com/pauljohnsmith82/status/107164856930664448 Paul
-
http://twitter.com/diddy121/status/107164881693835264 neil cleverley
-
http://twitter.com/bishara1995/status/107164926069575680 Abdulaziz Bishara
-
http://twitter.com/zaheerlfc/status/107165458519695360 Zaheer Bassa
-
http://twitter.com/aaronlaz/status/107165517286084608 Aaron Lazarus
-
http://twitter.com/foxley_3/status/107165758039146497 Ben Foxley
-
http://twitter.com/shai_bowman/status/107166281387622400 shai bowman
-
http://twitter.com/matcssd/status/107167528379363328 Matt Forrest
-
http://twitter.com/geleiterf/status/107167554870579200 Matthew
-
http://twitter.com/xfade09/status/107167711112597505 Will Yates
-
http://twitter.com/iamdamilare/status/107168014255919104 Ogunsanya Damilare
-
http://twitter.com/markpettifer65/status/107169114233122816 mark pettifer
-
http://twitter.com/getmetoadoctor/status/107169410845917184 Andrew Jacobs
-
http://twitter.com/heeee345/status/107169589112221696 Kevin Hempsted
-
http://twitter.com/sirhedge/status/107170551969222657 gordon highley
-
http://twitter.com/kebabbster/status/107171334768955392 Kris Babb
-
http://twitter.com/jcmorrison1985/status/107171500590768130 James Morrison
-
http://twitter.com/hueythered/status/107171718145126400 huey
-
http://twitter.com/tpybis/status/107172642729099264 thomas pybis
-
http://twitter.com/atebano/status/107172727667949569 Andy Tebano
-
http://twitter.com/dsiggers/status/107175193134366721 Darren Siggers
-
http://twitter.com/fsf_faircop/status/107175592516009984 Amanda Jacks
-
http://twitter.com/kaptainkenneth/status/107175644084969473 Anton Swemmer
-
http://twitter.com/david__keane/status/107176154204602370 David Keane
-
http://twitter.com/jonmoore1/status/107176294478909441 jon moore
-
http://twitter.com/wainy11/status/107176723577188352 Neil Wainwright
-
http://twitter.com/liammcfall/status/107177862431375360 liammcfall
-
http://twitter.com/liammcfall/status/107177862431375360 liammcfall
-
http://twitter.com/quacks61/status/107179019652444160 martin cornell
-
http://twitter.com/daramcdaid/status/107181093328916480 dara mcdaid
-
http://twitter.com/miichaelball/status/107181575539662848 Michael Ball
-
http://twitter.com/david__keane/status/107181762760818688 David Keane
-
http://twitter.com/markhendonufc/status/107181953660362754 Mark Henderson
-
http://twitter.com/lukereddy/status/107182166970085376 Luke Reddy
-
http://twitter.com/insightssoccer/status/107182762687070208 Thomas Hejduk
-
http://twitter.com/casualseagull/status/107183652819050497 Sean Burke
-
http://twitter.com/neilersmc/status/107183733832036352 Neil McCormick
-
http://twitter.com/raylfc1/status/107185679070539778 Andrew Mason
-
http://twitter.com/jackie9753/status/107186744432148482 Jackie Harrison
-
http://twitter.com/hilldog76/status/107187278677409792 Stephen Hill
-
http://twitter.com/backie9/status/107188848794152961 Rob Back
-
http://twitter.com/sirgungey/status/107189249115299840 Eugene Martin
-
http://twitter.com/mickylyonnn/status/107190322618056704 michael lyon
-
http://twitter.com/hippychick74/status/107191207624577024 Victoria Hubble
-
http://twitter.com/mattydyche/status/107191369709268992 Matthew Dyche
-
http://twitter.com/steg88/status/107192447657975808 Ste Gash
-
http://twitter.com/seanmacgabhann/status/107192860503314432 SeanMacGabhann
-
http://twitter.com/wullster/status/107193391137300480 M J Williamson
-
http://twitter.com/sickboy1/status/107194961505689600 steve metson
-
http://twitter.com/jenilee4/status/107195464042029057 jenilee davies
-
http://twitter.com/jussie_wussie/status/107195650831163393 Justine Porter
-
http://twitter.com/steeluv/status/107198548671602688 Stevie Withers
-
http://twitter.com/tigertracey/status/107208730071941120 Noel Tracey
-
http://twitter.com/connortation/status/107209040253288448 Stephen Connor
-
http://twitter.com/royboy4491/status/107209196285599745 Roy Wm Shakespeare
-
http://twitter.com/redmanmike/status/107211658631450624 Michael Roberts
-
http://twitter.com/thesage68/status/107212929937571840 Chris Watson
-
http://twitter.com/pikeyhayes/status/107217762383953921 Eddy Hayes
-
http://twitter.com/pikeyhayes/status/107220239674122240 Eddy Hayes
-
http://twitter.com/3plustwo/status/107222569849069568 mememememe
-
http://twitter.com/3plustwo/status/107222569849069568 mememememe
-
http://twitter.com/lukewildman88/status/107225113920933888 Luke WIldman
-
http://twitter.com/mactravel1990s/status/107225821969780736 Andrew McManus
-
http://twitter.com/embyr1/status/107231890863435776 Emma Boo-urns
-
http://twitter.com/alistairhudson/status/107232484730740736 Alistair Hudson
-
http://twitter.com/stalkerdenx/status/107238752530874368 den
-
http://twitter.com/jona79135/status/107241319914672128 Jonathan Fletcher
-
http://twitter.com/gribbenp/status/107243310573301760 Paul Gribben
-
http://twitter.com/redman_18/status/107254381413543936 Chris Coates
-
http://www.theliverpoolview.com Baadier
-
http://twitter.com/oban1995/status/107335798726205440 Bill
-
http://newcastlechronicle mark Bonnd
-
http://twitter.com/gavhobbs/status/107368695269031936 Gavin Hobbs
-
http://twitter.com/stevencole1976/status/107369928859979776 Steven Cole
-
http://twitter.com/markporton/status/107369997382332416 mark porton
-
http://twitter.com/mm_undisputed/status/107372933562904576 Michael McCulloch
-
http://twitter.com/paulburr/status/107373003750379520 Paul C Burr
-
http://twitter.com/asitseemstome/status/107380352946941952 Fiona McMahon
-
http://twitter.com/tjblackster/status/107393213152768000 tony black
-
http://twitter.com/nooobzz/status/107394362228490240 Abdullah k al-nabhan
-
http://twitter.com/melgamike/status/107409647958364162 dé mérré balxóc
-
http://twitter.com/sir_k_dalglish/status/107433358774120448 Sir Kenny Dalglish
-
http://twitter.com/sir_k_dalglish/status/107437382487384064 Sir Kenny Dalglish
-
http://twitter.com/smorgan66/status/107448069834018816 shane morgan
-
http://twitter.com/gazzaq/status/107458689824325632 Gary Quattromini
-
http://twitter.com/caileanjrgall/status/107519730117648384 Cailean Gall
-
http://twitter.com/steroche/status/107525931303833601 Stephen Roche
-
http://twitter.com/mickmcluskey/status/107556846008672256 Michael McLuskey
-
http://twitter.com/richardjchurch/status/107582304452493313 Richard Church
-
http://twitter.com/hudo/status/107590619437867009 Steve Hudson
-
http://twitter.com/tonydowling/status/107601556177825793 Tony Dowling
-
http://jiveblogger.com/2011/08/liverpool-was-not-shocked-by-phone-hacking-scandal-belfast-telegraph/ Liverpool was not shocked by phone-hacking scandal – Belfast Telegraph | Jiveblogger.com
-
http://twitter.com/jcsmithnz/status/107673175185297408 James Smith
-
http://twitter.com/rumnique/status/107774731742220289 rumnique
-
http://twitter.com/jonoeng/status/107915872408051712 Jon Cockrell
-
george firewood
-
http://twitter.com/sandeepshenoy7/status/108048832432046080 Sandeep
-
http://twitter.com/monocleoptical/status/108190047777456128 monOcleOptical
-
http://twitter.com/mingerzinho/status/108518212534140928 Camopi Minger
-
http://twitter.com/liamporter92/status/108618073585614848 Liam Porter
-
http://twitter.com/bristolcwu/status/108874307689648128 Dave Wilshire
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6g4IqLxK_6I Bob
-
http://twitter.com/stevewraith/status/109988915670302720 steve wraith
-
http://twitter.com/ruv1966/status/111456583183114241 Martin Rutherford
-
http://twitter.com/da23rdtank/status/153083848836644864 ✌Da❷❸rdTANK✌
-
http://twitter.com/da23rdtank/status/153083848836644864 ✌Da❷❸rdTANK✌
-
http://twitter.com/michaelje67/status/153090725960093697 michael emonds
-
http://twitter.com/michaelje67/status/153090725960093697 michael emonds
-
http://twitter.com/jintyg51/status/153090970504794113 Janet Graham
-
http://twitter.com/jintyg51/status/153090970504794113 Janet Graham
-
http://twitter.com/theonlytait/status/153093416648060928 Adam Tait
-
http://twitter.com/kevinpmeagher/status/153111324732293120 Kevin Meagher
-
http://twitter.com/lutheblue/status/153189705213681664 Lucy Ashton
-
http://twitter.com/jennifermor/status/153204271570092033 jenny morris
YouGov Tracker
ToUChstone Economic Tracker
George’s Marvellous Deficit Calculator
Most read this week
- Week Outside Westminster: Is Cameron a separatist sleeper-cell?
- "You've never had it so good" has never been so wrong: Review of The Cost of Inequality
- Tory voters trust BMA and co. over Cameron and Lansley on the NHS
- German superunion to begin negotiating for 6.5 per cent wage increase
- Building social housing would cut the housing benefit bill three times faster than a cap
Best of the web
Top issues
Left Foot Facebook
Awards & Rankings
Archive
Tag Cloud
Domestic Progressives
- A Thousand Cuts
- Alastair Campbell
- Andrew Gibson's Blog
- Anthony Painter
- Ayes To The Left
- Blackburn Labour Party
- Chartist
- Conor's Commentary
- Dave's Part
- Diary of a Benefit Scrounger
- Duncan's Economic Blog
- Follow my leaders
- Freemania
- Full Fact
- Go Fourth
- Good Animal / Bad Animal
- Guardian Politics blog
- Harry's Place
- Hopi Sen
- Institute for Government
- Intelligence Squared
- Labour and Capital
- Labour Home
- Labour List
- LabourHome
- Left Central
- Lib-Con Trick
- Liberal Conspiracy
- Liberal Democrat Voice
- LSE politics blog
- Luke's blog
- Mark Thompson Blog
- Matthew Taylor's blog
- Max Atkinson's blog
- Migrants' Rights Network
- New Statesman: free speech
- Next Left
- Nick Pearce
- OurKingdom
- Patrick Bury's blog
- Policy Critical
- Political Reboot
- Political Scrapbook
- Progress
- Red Brick
- RSA Projects
- Runnymede Trust
- Rupa Huq's Blog
- Sadie's Tavern
- Save EMA
- Shamik Das
- Slinger blog
- Tank the Tories
- Tax Research UK
- The Centre Left
- The Green Benches
- The Novocastrian
- This is my truth
- Tim McLoughlin
- Tom Harris MP
- Tom Watson MP
- Touchstone
- Touchstone TUC blog
- Young Fabians Blog







