Miliband shooting par for leader of the opposition – no more, no less

The lead-up to the Labour conference has not been easy for Ed Miliband. Fresh from being booed at the Trade Union Congress (admittedly no longer the love-in it once was for a Labour leader) after repeating his belief the strikes in June were a mistake while negotiations were still going on, he was greeted with the news his own party can’t see him as a leader.

Ed-Miliband-Labour-Party-Conference
A Populous poll for the Times (£) found almost half of Labour’s supporters find it difficult to see him in Downing Street, while the numbers for the general public are even worse, with 63 per cent reporting that they can’t imagine him running the country.

Supporters of Miliband could quite easily follow their leader and ignore the news:

What does he say to those who don’t think he has what it takes to make it to No 10? “They’re wrong,” he says flatly. What about the recent Populus poll showing 49 per cent of Labour voters could not see him as prime minister? “Honestly, I notice these things but I don’t take much notice of them,” he replies, with a shrug of his shoulders.

On the other hand, the same Populous poll contains some remarkably good numbers for Labour as well, which are worth picking out. They are improving their lead over the Tories, with their margin over the former up by one point to four, and maintaining their 26 point lead over the Lib Dems.

The Times also reports:

The poll has found that Labour is seen as the most “honest and principled” of the three parties and more people say that they share the same values as Labour than either the Tories or Lib Dems.

In addition, Labour is seen as the more trusted party on a variety of issues, including maintaining a stunning 30 point lead over the Conservatives on the NHS. Given this was once literally Cameron’s billboard issue, if that margin can be kept then Labour will have an easy point of attack when the time comes.

It may be enough to say that Labour remains strong as a party while having an unfortunately weak leader, but even that may not be the case.

A new report, to be published in the Fabian Review conference special and excerpted in the Indy, compares Miliband with former leaders of the opposition from Hague onwards, and finds that a year-one slump is pretty much the standard.

Net satisfaction with William Hague fell by 22 points, Iain Duncan Smith by 17, Michael Howard by 30 points, and David Cameron by 23 points. Indeed, looking back at trackers since 1978 you see a very similar story for Neil Kinnock, Michael Foot (albeit from a much lower starting point) and even Margaret Thatcher. In the year or so since he took over, Ed Miliband’s favourability has dropped from +9 to -7, right in line with the best of them.

The real question is not whether this drop marks Miliband out as a failure to launch, but whether he’ll be able to capture the uptick that both Cameron and Howard received in their second year, which marks them out as the successes compared to Hague and IDS’s continued fall.

As he enters his second year, he needs to keep an eye on the qualities marked out by the Fabian Review focus group as most important for a good leader: Integrity, decisiveness, and communication and listening skills. Currently voters rank him well on the first and last of those, while Cameron maintains a daunting lead on the middle two.

But the broader point to take from all of this is that it is not surprising that people can’t see Ed as a leader yet; with just over a year since he took over, he has simply not had the chance to demonstrate his credentials. Eventually he’ll have had enough chances to behave in a statesmanlike manner, and when that time comes, we can read more into these polls.

For now, he needs to focus on building a solid base to progress there from.

See also:

• To renew, Labour must understand the trends shaping modern Britain – Will Straw, September 22nd 2011

• As conference season approaches, economic reality begins to dawn for coalition – Shamik Das, September 16th 2011

• Will Osborne alter course? And how should Labour respond? – Matthew Pitt, September 15th 2011

• Miliband v Murdoch: Can Ed win this “battle to the death”? – Shamik Das, July 12th 2011

• Milibands face challenge with ‘mainstream’ voters – Richard Darlington, September 25th 2010

http://twitter.com/hoganist/status/117222885684297729 Dan Hogan

"a year-one slump is pretty much the standard" for opposition leaders, even future PMs. http://t.co/1USiUx6L
http://twitter.com/rolandmarden/status/117225161236811776 Roland Marden

49 per cent of Labour voters do not see #Milliband as a prospective PM http://ow.ly/6CNyD #labour
http://twitter.com/therightarticle/status/117230444797374465 Michael

Miliband shooting par for leader of the opposition – no more, no less l Left Foot Forward – http://j.mp/p5yA47
http://twitter.com/debsalini/status/117232855146446848 Deborah Segalini

Miliband shooting par for leader of the opposition – no more, no less l Left Foot Forward – http://j.mp/p5yA47
http://www.politics247.net/obama-fundraising-inspires-labour-financial-times/ Obama fundraising inspires Labour – Financial Times | Politics 247

[...] for donations under attempts to widen the party's funding model, under plans by Ed …Miliband shooting par for leader of the opposition – no more, no lessLeft Foot ForwardBritain's Labour PartyThe EconomistMiliband limbers up for Labour's big [...]
http://twitter.com/labour52rose/status/117267616275505152 Alex Braithwaite

RT @leftfootfwd: Miliband shooting par for leader of the opposition – no more, no less http://t.co/57MsFeqy
http://twitter.com/shamikdas/status/117332164072312832 Shamik Das

Gd analysis: RT @leftfootfwd: . @Ed_Miliband shooting par for leader of the opposition – no more, no less: http://t.co/0YNPywg9 by @AlexHern
Robert

Four labour MP’s in court and about ten more who should have gone to court, another labour MP going to court who will no doubt get jail, and labour is seen as trusted whom ever are doing these polls must be pissed half the time.

Whether you like it or not Brown took the banks and the country into this mess with a crossed eyed American Pratt of a leader.

I suspect those who do these Polls will be thinking at the next election do we really trust this bunch of morons, Ed is a boy lost in a mans world, he likes the idea of a blue labour party, he thinks Purple Labour has a good change, and yet he’s going to rip up the rule book top make a new start as a mini Tory party.

God help us all.
http://www.leftfootforward.org/2011/09/look-left-23-09-11/ Look Left – “Six weeks to save the euro” warns Osborne | Left Foot Forward

[...] Alex Hern looked at Miliband’s first year compared to previous leaders of the opposition, concluding he was “shooting par… no more, no [...]
http://www.leftfootforward.org/2011/09/leading-labour-evaluating-ed-miliband%e2%80%99s-first-year/ Leading Labour: Evaluating Ed Miliband’s first year | Left Foot Forward

[...] also: • Miliband shooting par for leader of the opposition – no more, no less – Alex Hern, September 23rd [...]
ted

I agree with Robert. Ed is out of his depth and lacks the vision required to provide a narrative to the wider public. I joined the party recently and wish some of the “core” supporters would objectively evaluate the leader and reach this obvious conclusion.

secondly, we need to restore out trust regarding the economy – a well crafted apology could turn this to our advantage. Not talking about it essentially admits defeat. Cameron was successful because he convinced the public you could trust him with public services – ed needs a similar approach

he could just ask to borrow his brother’s unused leadership acceptance speech
ted

I agree with Robert. Ed is out of his depth and lacks the vision required to provide a narrative to the wider public. I joined the party recently and wish some of the “core” supporters would objectively evaluate the leader and reach this obvious conclusion.

secondly, we need to restore out trust regarding the economy – a well crafted apology could turn this to our advantage. Not talking about it essentially admits defeat. Cameron was successful because he convinced the public you could trust him with public services – ed needs a similar approach

he could just ask to borrow his brother’s unused leadership acceptance speech
http://twitter.com/jossgarman/status/118598203988914176 Joss Garman

@AndrewSparrow this? http://t.co/KaUTLyAn
http://leedsclassifieds.com/latest-news/labour-conference-2011-live-coverage.html Labour conference 2011: live coverage | Leeds Classifieds

[...] .• Alex Hern at Left Foot Forward says that a slump in ratings is usual for an opposition leader af… As he enters his second year, he needs to keep an eye on the qualities marked out by the Fabian Review focus group as most important for a good leader: Integrity, decisiveness, and communication and listening skills. Currently voters rank him well on the first and last of those, while Cameron maintains a daunting lead on the middle two. [...]
http://maagg.com/?p=456 Labour conference 2011: reside protection | maagg.com

[...] .• Alex Hern at Left Foot Forward says that a slump in ratings is usual for an opposition leader af… As he enters his second year, he needs to keep an eye on the qualities marked out by the Fabian Review focus group as most important for a good leader: Integrity, decisiveness, and communication and listening skills. Currently voters rank him well on the first and last of those, while Cameron maintains a daunting lead on the middle two. [...]
http://politics.zonkeyblog.co.uk/guardian/labour-conference-live-coverage/ Labour conference: live coverage | Politics News and Discussion

[...] .• Alex Hern at Left Foot Forward says that a slump in ratings is usual for an opposition leader af… As he enters his second year, he needs to keep an eye on the qualities marked out by the Fabian Review focus group as most important for a good leader: Integrity, decisiveness, and communication and listening skills. Currently voters rank him well on the first and last of those, while Cameron maintains a daunting lead on the middle two. [...]
http://www.leftfootforward.org/2011/09/one-tory-is-tired-of-being-in-the-nasty-party/ One Tory is tired of being in the nasty party | Left Foot Forward

[...] should rightly be concerned about the figures from YouGov showing that 42 per cent of voters would never vote Tory, he argued that unless voter’s concerns were addressed, the Conservative’s [...]
http://www.leftfootforward.org/2011/10/the-purple-book-is-bland-and-tragic/ The Purple Book: Bland and tragic | Left Foot Forward

[...] Miliband shooting par for leader of the opposition – no more, no less – Alex Hern, September 23rd [...]
http://www.leftfootforward.org/2012/01/conservatives-retain-the-lead-nationally-is-this-the-new-normal/ Conservatives retain the lead nationally; Is this the new normal? | Left Foot Forward

[...] Miliband shooting par for leader of the opposition – no more, no less – Alex Hern, September 23rd 2011 Share | Permalink | Leave a comment [...]