548 views
Public Services for All > Published by Alex Hern, January 19th 2012 at 7:00 pm

The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed

Print Friendly

 

One year on from the introduction of the health and social care bill into the house of commons, and the day that the Royal College of Midwives and the Royal College of Nursing have declared their “outright opposition” to the bill, it is worth looking back at why it is that the bill still incites such opposition.

1. Breaking the link of legal and parliamentary responsibility of the secretary of state for health for the delivery of a comprehensive health service.

As Jos Bell wrote in her parliamentary sketch:

Secretary of state Lansley has done all he can to abdicate ‘the duty of the secretary of state for health to secure the provision of services under Section 1 of the NHS Act’, placing instead those duties on clinical commissioning groups and Monitor…

So where exactly – as Lord McKay later said – does the buck stop? If not the SoS then who will ultimately bear responsibility for maintaining a health service free at the point of need for all?

To ignore this, would, as Baroness Williams said ‘leave us in a world of deep twilight uncertainty’ for Lansley has serially failed to acknowledge that this will also result in a danger to provision in areas where the infrastructure fails - or indeed in the management of national emergencies.

2. Creating an economic regulator similar to Offgem and Offwat to ensure health services are bought and sold through a competitive market.

The bill requires Monitor to ‘prevent anti-competitive practice’.

As Tim Holmes wrote on the eve of UK Uncut’s protest over the bill:

With sharp constraints on the NHS budget in place, this can only force incumbents into atrophy or collapse. Profit-motivated companies are likely to cherry-pick the operations they provide, offering cheap, easy treatments, and leaving the public to pick up the tab for the rest. By competing toundercut each other, they could drive down standards across the board.

3. The lifting of the private patient cap, or setting of a limit of 49%, which sends a damaging message of the place of private income generation within NHS, at the expense of patient care.

Dr Kailash Chand explained the problem with this (and urges you to sign his petition against the bill):

Removing the barriers will mean that waiting lists will target patients with higher resources than the NHS tariff, private patients will be prioritised over NHS patients, and the real threat is that the elderly and the vulnerable, those with chronic mental health problems, those with chronic medical problems such as diabetics, renal patients, etc will be a low priority.

There is every possibility that the reformed NHS under these proposals will become exclusive rather than inclusive. Removal of a cap over private income will see Foundation Trusts competing over costs rather than quality, so that those that are run by poor management will risk the stability of the hospital to a much greater extent than prevails now.

4. Creation of a legalistic and complex bureaucracy which will lead our NHS to insurance base and huge costs not spent on patient care, through the use of EU procurement legislation, competition act and Office of Fair Trade

Dominic Browne detailed the changes in June:

In its response to the NHS Future Forum listening exercise (pdf) the government aims to create clinical senates, commissioning consortiums, health and wellbeing boards, a national commissioning board.That’s four types of bureaucracies for the price of the current two: Primary Care Trusts (PCTs) and Strategic Health Authorities (SHAs).

How much extra bureaucracy will this mean on the ground? See if you can untangle it for yourself:The clinical commissioning groups will need “authorisation” from the national commissioning board with “input from health and wellbeing boards and local clinicians”. If they don’t get authorisation they might exist in “shadow form”.

5. The risks and cost for patients, staff and managers in the NHS – at least three years potential progress lost in fragmentation of decision making, increased waiting lists, lack of collaboration and loss of expertise.

As we revealed exclusively on Left Foot Forward, the NHS risk register for London details concerns over the negative impact of the reforms:

The consequence of this risk could be that the transformational changes in health services envisaged in London’s QIPP plans in response to the clear clinical case for change, may not be realised in full or are delayed, thereby undermining significant improvements in the health of Londoners.

While all the focus is on the government’s top-down re-organisation of the NHS, the negative aspects of their minor health policies have gone by largely unnoticed, including it, seems, by the department itself. It took them eighteen months to reverse their damaging no-targets policy, which has now led to 43 per cent of patients waiting too long for treatment.

See also:

• NHS assessment of Lansley’s plan’s risk makes for sober reading – Alex Hern, November 24th 2011

• How Tories wrecked the NHS (but learnt to love targets (too late)) – Alex Hern, November 17th 2011

• The House of Lords ties itself in noble knots over the NHS bill – Jos Bell, November 12th 2011

• UK Uncut: Stop the traffic to stop the NHS being run over – Tim Holmes, October 7th 2011

• Tories: The party of NHS bureaucracy – Dominic Browne, June 15th 2011

  • http://twitter.com/patronpress/status/160080471986941954 Patron Press – #P2

    #UK : The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/URiNcx9w

  • http://twitter.com/dratnaike/status/160081778982387712 Dànaidh Ratnaike

    The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/RS8IolcN @alexhern

  • http://twitter.com/sebalexander/status/160083912503214080 Seb Alexander

    The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed: http://t.co/f6ZD8Muh by @alexhern

  • http://twitter.com/eadgifu/status/160087528140062720 Izzy Green

    The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed: http://t.co/f6ZD8Muh by @alexhern

  • http://twitter.com/kaalgroup/status/160087702530834432 KAAL Group

    The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed: http://t.co/f6ZD8Muh by @alexhern

  • http://twitter.com/steve_trow/status/160093829293285376 Steve Trow

    The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed: http://t.co/f6ZD8Muh by @alexhern

  • http://twitter.com/dafidius/status/160099362364592129 DPWF

    RT @leftfootfwd: The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/eCH7CeG9 I can think of a few further reasons too.

  • http://twitter.com/britishroses1/status/160109348289388544 BevR

    The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed: http://t.co/f6ZD8Muh by @alexhern

  • http://twitter.com/ivanwhite48/status/160118241400848384 Ivan White

    The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed: http://t.co/f6ZD8Muh by @alexhern

  • Mr. Sensible

    This bill is in a complete mess and should be dropped.

  • http://twitter.com/britishroses1/status/160129689011236864 BevR

    RT @leftfootfwd: The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/pIepU2de #spartacusreport

  • http://twitter.com/therightarticle/status/160277243199881216 Michael

    The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed I Left Foot Forward – http://t.co/z8kRlVSt

  • http://twitter.com/cameronsfollys/status/160284335172362241 cameronsfollys

    #NO2nhsPRIVATISATION The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/zVB3dqFy http://t.co/0vEoA2Ah

  • http://twitter.com/tracycartmell/status/160284614726914048 Tracy Cartmell

    #NO2nhsPRIVATISATION The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/zVB3dqFy http://t.co/0vEoA2Ah

  • http://twitter.com/clarionsingers/status/160285370725052416 Birmingham Clarion

    The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed I Left Foot Forward – http://t.co/z8kRlVSt

  • http://twitter.com/britishroses1/status/160300597743071233 BevR

    RT @leftfootfwd: The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/pIepU2de #spartacusreport

  • http://twitter.com/poutingpou/status/160301106583453696 Kyron Hodgetts

    RT @leftfootfwd: The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/pIepU2de #spartacusreport

  • http://twitter.com/pinkichiban/status/160302673290215424 Emma

    RT @leftfootfwd: The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/pIepU2de #spartacusreport

  • http://twitter.com/kailashchandobe/status/160316920296521729 Dr Kailash Chand OBE

    RT @leftfootfwd: The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/EgVmqwAo Please RT

  • http://twitter.com/kailashchandobe/status/160317739242766336 Dr Kailash Chand OBE

    RT @leftfootfwd: The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/EgVmqwAo
    Sign RT http://t.co/pWUbpbQG #dropthebill

  • http://twitter.com/mattleys/status/160319135379755008 Matt Leys

    RT @leftfootfwd: The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/EgVmqwAo
    Sign RT http://t.co/pWUbpbQG #dropthebill

  • http://twitter.com/chez_em/status/160319361318531073 Chez_Em

    RT @leftfootfwd: The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/EgVmqwAo
    Sign RT http://t.co/pWUbpbQG #dropthebill

  • http://twitter.com/jeremysmith98/status/160321000020516864 Jeremy Smith

    RT @leftfootfwd: The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/EgVmqwAo
    Sign RT http://t.co/pWUbpbQG #dropthebill

  • http://twitter.com/la_rambler/status/160321716902559744 La Rambler

    RT @leftfootfwd: The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/EgVmqwAo
    Sign RT http://t.co/pWUbpbQG #dropthebill

  • http://twitter.com/unisonournhs/status/160328422386704385 UNISON Health

    Five reasons why the NHS Bill is still being opposed #DropTheBill http://t.co/zxn6ADva

  • http://twitter.com/p_a_r_a_medic/status/160328490703527936 P_a_r_a_medic

    Five reasons why the NHS Bill is still being opposed #DropTheBill http://t.co/zxn6ADva

  • http://twitter.com/justjayne4/status/160330451121225728 Jayne Hornby

    RT @leftfootfwd: The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/UHc57qxt

  • http://twitter.com/himwiththecyst/status/160333434538049536 Michael Jones

    RT @leftfootfwd: The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/EgVmqwAo
    Sign RT http://t.co/pWUbpbQG #dropthebill

  • http://twitter.com/mellojonny/status/160334981800017922 Jonathon Tomlinson

    "The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/SNxC8Rrn Sign RT http://t.co/9kb0GWQ2 #dropthebill"

  • http://twitter.com/mgtmccartney/status/160335600099147776 margaretmccartney

    "The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/SNxC8Rrn Sign RT http://t.co/9kb0GWQ2 #dropthebill"

  • http://twitter.com/falseecon/status/160335718374309888 False Economy

    The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed: http://t.co/f6ZD8Muh by @alexhern

  • http://twitter.com/gismotigga/status/160335978932875264 sarah ann james

    "The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/SNxC8Rrn Sign RT http://t.co/9kb0GWQ2 #dropthebill"

  • Rachit

    I would have thought one of the criticisms, important enough to be included here, is that the reforms come at a time when the NHS is being asked to save £20bn from its budget over 4 years (supposedly to pay for rising costs) – i.e. that regardless of the de-/merits of the reforms, the timing is completely wrong.

  • http://twitter.com/samtarry/status/160336324648370179 Samuel Tarry

    The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed: http://t.co/f6ZD8Muh by @alexhern

  • http://twitter.com/drgrumble/status/160336359599521792 John Grumble

    "The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/SNxC8Rrn Sign RT http://t.co/9kb0GWQ2 #dropthebill"

  • http://twitter.com/daveyboybish/status/160336458949992449 David Bishop

    RT @leftfootfwd: The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/b2PnSU57

  • http://twitter.com/lambethnut/status/160336569717374977 Lambeth NUT

    The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed: http://t.co/f6ZD8Muh by @alexhern

  • http://twitter.com/iainpics/status/160336680916762624 Iain Peacock

    The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed: http://t.co/f6ZD8Muh by @alexhern

  • http://twitter.com/tigercat1/status/160337258300440577 tigercat1

    The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed: http://t.co/f6ZD8Muh by @alexhern

  • http://twitter.com/darlodoug/status/160337313820454912 Doug James

    RT @leftfootfwd: The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/0icKhTrw – Declare your outright opposition too

  • http://twitter.com/titansholster/status/160337323513483264 Titas Halder

    The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed: http://t.co/f6ZD8Muh by @alexhern

  • http://twitter.com/awkwardcyclist/status/160337712539373568 Andy Ward

    "The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/SNxC8Rrn Sign RT http://t.co/9kb0GWQ2 #dropthebill"

  • http://twitter.com/p0bsta/status/160338045734879233 Jason Taylor

    The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed: http://t.co/f6ZD8Muh by @alexhern

  • Saccroft

    Excellent article, very clear and to the point. I have reposted it at my blog, LifeinCharity.blogspot.com

  • http://twitter.com/scoscarwood/status/160437943499108352 Celia Kelly

    #NO2nhsPRIVATISATION The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/zVB3dqFy http://t.co/0vEoA2Ah

  • http://twitter.com/kailashchandobe/status/160449590007566336 Dr Kailash Chand OBE

    @leftfootfwd:Well argued five reasons why #Healthbill isunsafe unacceptable http://t.co/EgVmqwAo Sign RT http://t.co/pWUbpbQG #dropthebill

  • http://twitter.com/hackneykonp/status/160453927878410240 HackneyKONP

    @leftfootfwd:Well argued five reasons why #Healthbill isunsafe unacceptable http://t.co/EgVmqwAo Sign RT http://t.co/pWUbpbQG #dropthebill

  • http://twitter.com/pannaj/status/160476751015841793 Anna Jones

    @mattleys please can you RT Five reasons why the NHS bill still being opposed http://t.co/8MfnOGXw
    http://t.co/3tcfVQWY #DropTheBill

  • http://twitter.com/mattleys/status/160495591774887936 Matt Leys

    Five reasons why the NHS Bill still being opposed: http://t.co/EvjB7nHV Sign the petition! http://t.co/wSrQIlue #DropTheBill (via @pannaj)

  • http://twitter.com/jos21/status/160495851725266944 Jos Bell

    Five reasons why the NHS Bill still being opposed: http://t.co/EvjB7nHV Sign the petition! http://t.co/wSrQIlue #DropTheBill (via @pannaj)

  • http://twitter.com/cornettofairy/status/160496781090758656 Jenette Passmore

    Five reasons why the NHS Bill still being opposed: http://t.co/EvjB7nHV Sign the petition! http://t.co/wSrQIlue #DropTheBill (via @pannaj)

  • http://twitter.com/mpatton62 Matthew Patton

    If this passes, someone should force Cameron to get his healthcare from NHS–and she how he likes it . . .

  • http://twitter.com/tractorgirly/status/160498415913013248 John Wark (or am I?)

    Five reasons why the NHS Bill still being opposed: http://t.co/EvjB7nHV Sign the petition! http://t.co/wSrQIlue #DropTheBill (via @pannaj)

  • http://twitter.com/wickedandwelsh/status/160499908179263488 Amanda Shepherd

    Five reasons why the NHS Bill still being opposed: http://t.co/EvjB7nHV Sign the petition! http://t.co/wSrQIlue #DropTheBill (via @pannaj)

  • http://twitter.com/geum/status/160548472091709440 Jim K

    Five reasons why the NHS Bill still being opposed: http://t.co/EvjB7nHV Sign the petition! http://t.co/wSrQIlue #DropTheBill (via @pannaj)

  • http://twitter.com/petermbenglish/status/160697267232317440 Peter English

    Left Foot Forward – five reasons for opposing the health bill.http://bit.ly/yKQrW3

  • http://twitter.com/sebkraemer/status/160704514201100288 sebastian kraemer

    RT @leftfootfwd: The five reasons why the #NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/BeT8Txpb #dropthebill #savethenhs

  • http://twitter.com/saveournhs1/status/160707713393893376 SaveNHS e-petition

    RT @leftfootfwd: The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/EgVmqwAo
    Sign RT http://t.co/pWUbpbQG #dropthebill

  • http://twitter.com/tghelani/status/160999799297015808 t.ghelani

    @leftfootfwd:Well argued five reasons why #Healthbill isunsafe unacceptable http://t.co/EgVmqwAo Sign RT http://t.co/pWUbpbQG #dropthebill

  • http://twitter.com/keithglue/status/161751945449713664 Keith Birnie

    RT @leftfootfwd: The five reasons why the NHS bill is still being opposed http://t.co/qrc3Z8K4

  • http://www.leftfootforward.org/2012/01/national-libraries-day-february-4-2012/ As National Libraries Day nears, our libraries remain under threat | Left Foot Forward

    [...] may be overshadowed by the attacks on the NHS, the disabled, and the poor, but the coalition’s attacks on Britain’s library system [...]