Greece is a smokescreen to hide the mother of all bank bailouts
By Nick Dearden of the Jubilee Debt Campaign
Eurozone finance ministers who sat in Brussels and decide Greece’s future last night should have attended yesterday’s well-timed University of London conference on learning lessons from Latin America.
The central lesson is of urgent importance: that the economic policies pushed on Latin America in the early 1980s were an excellent way of helping US banks out of crisis, but an appalling way of resolving Latin America’s debt crisis, instead creating two decades of more debt, poverty and inequality.
Of course, this was the precise purpose of these policies – to shift the burden of financial crisis from the financial system and onto developing nations.

The International Monetary Fund and World Bank lent money to dozens of countries which would otherwise have defaulted, in order to keep the debt repayments flowing back to the banks of the rich world who had created the crisis by their own reckless strategies.
Then, those countries, which benefited not at all from these ‘bail-out’ funds, were told to implement structural adjustment policies which saw industry privatised, money freed from government control and markets ripped open to competition with well-subsidised companies from the US and Europe. Poverty boomed, inequality soared and finance was proclaimed king.
The same logic lies barely concealed behind the Greece ’bail-out’ being agreed by European finance ministers today. There is not even a pretence that Greece’s people will benefit from these funds.
It is recognised that what Greek unions call the ‘barbaric’ additional austerity measures Greece has to implement in order to receive these funds will lead to stagnation and unemployment detrimental to repaying debt. By 2020 Greece’s debts will still represent an unsustainable 120 per cent of the country’s GDP – and that’s if things go very very well.
The slashing of pensions by another 13 per cent and the minimum wage by 22 per cent, and the large reduction in spending with concomitant public sector job losses, can only make the depression longer and deeper. Even the Credit Ratings Agencies have recognised the futility of forcing countries into ongoing stagnation.
So what’s the point of the ‘bail-out’? To keep the money flowing into the European financial system. Indeed the likely creation of an escrow account will mean that Greece’s people are by-passed entirely – money will be lent from European institutions, ultimately tax payers money – and flow out into the coffers of European banks. It is a bank bail-out on a gigantic scale.
But the good news for the banks doesn’t end there. By forcing Greece to speed up its €50 billion privatisation programme, all sorts of goodies – from airports, ports and motorways to water and sewerage systems – will come up for sale to be snatched up by the financiers of the countries imposing the policies.
The ‘bail-outs’, the severe public spending cuts, the onslaught on public ownership – all reflect the experience of the developing world in the 1980s and ’90s. The result was two lost decades of development.
Up until this point it was unusual for countries to go backwards in terms of their income levels. But during the 1990s 54 countries went backwards in terms of per capita income and the number of extreme poverty increased by 100 million – not because of war or natural disaster but debt and structural adjustment.
Human welfare was sacrificed to the diktats of the financial system. The increased rates of murder, suicide and HIV in Greece today paint a similar picture.
There are alternatives which Europe could learn from.
After the Second World War Germany received massive debt cancellation and its repayments on the remaining debt were explicitly linked to the country’s growth.
But the Greek people have to wait on European largesse. While there is no pain-free answer to a debt crisis, when governments stand up to the power of their creditors by defaulting, by auditing their debts or by insisting on their own terms for repayment – from Argentina to Ecuador to Iceland – they have fared markedly better.
Moreover, they have made some attempts at regaining their sovereignty from the whims of an unstable financial system.
These solutions seem beyond the vision or courage of European governments, but they are solutions increasingly being looked to by the people of Europe.
No wonder that Germany’s finance minister has put forward the idea both that a ‘Commissar’ is appointed to oversee the Euro protectorate of Greece or, failing that, that democracy be indefinitely suspended. This is the logical conclusion of viewing people primarily as an obstacle to the repayment of your banks.
We propose a different logic: when debt cannot be paid we need to stop punishing the people least responsible and start looking at changing the rules governing those who are responsible.
See also:
• ‘What Hague had to say was absolute crap’: A masterclass in economic communication - Alex Hern, February 20th 2012
• Osborne’s austerity obsession is betraying a generation of young people - William Bain MP, February 16th 2012
• The UK isn’t Greece, it’s Iceland - Alex Hern, December 21st 2011
• What happens when Greece defaults? - George Irvin, November 25th 2011
• Time to move beyond the eurozone - Barry Gardiner MP, September 21st 2011
-
http://twitter.com/politicalplanet/status/171906258532696065 Political Planet
-
http://twitter.com/britishroses1/status/171907308517998592 BevR
-
http://twitter.com/daflyingbanana/status/171908803288252416 NO flying MONKEYzzz!
-
http://twitter.com/wlate17/status/171909632950943744 Marverde
-
http://twitter.com/blake3987/status/171909724529360896 Brad M
-
http://twitter.com/beckonstruth/status/171910190248103936 TruthBeckons
-
http://twitter.com/leftlinks/status/171910198724800512 leftlinks
-
http://twitter.com/pulpark/status/171911638918774784 Pulp Ark
-
http://twitter.com/paulemetz/status/171912574345035777 Paul Metz
-
http://twitter.com/hens4freedom/status/171912698337034241 Hens4Freedom
-
http://twitter.com/annakotzia/status/171914608007852032 anna kotzia
-
http://twitter.com/evdoxial/status/171915163673427968 Evdoxia Lymperi
-
http://twitter.com/all_thats_left_ All Thats Left
-
Anonymous
-
Anonymous
-
Curious
-
Anonymous
-
http://twitter.com/twitt_odg/status/171976121204752385 Observatori Deute
-
http://twitter.com/_interferencies/status/171976125243854850 Interferències
-
http://twitter.com/tomasldb/status/171983508095512576 Tomas
-
http://twitter.com/stevegpreston/status/171996108250296320 Steve Preston
-
http://twitter.com/jubileeusa/status/171998943432024064 Jubilee USA Network
-
http://twitter.com/msee/status/172025039015784449 msee
-
http://twitter.com/makiwa/status/172073269015486464 Neil
-
http://twitter.com/luismorago/status/172074142965833728 Luis Morago
-
http://twitter.com/charliemuppet/status/172095735586766849 simonp
-
http://twitter.com/h4364r/status/172203833148194816 h4364r
-
http://twitter.com/copwatcher/status/172275907791302656 Kevin Blowe
-
http://twitter.com/a6ruled/status/172276908887781377 Richard
-
http://twitter.com/adpucci/status/172278122589335553 Pucci D
-
http://twitter.com/freebesieged/status/172279959535095808 Maggie Aitch
-
http://twitter.com/comhlamh/status/172338992447111168 Comhlámh
-
http://twitter.com/soundmigration/status/172350674154172418 Mark Malone
-
http://twitter.com/notourdebt/status/172350713844858881 Debt Justice Action
-
http://twitter.com/abiepb/status/172351026182094848 Abie Philbin Bowman
-
http://www.leftfootforward.org/2012/02/greece-bailout-austerity-armageddon/ Greece’s Armageddon: Could the military seize power to ‘restore order’? | Left Foot Forward
-
http://twitter.com/gilliali/status/172421555182252035 Alison Gilliland
-
http://twitter.com/achilleasz/status/172426277704310785 Achilleas Zapranis
-
http://twitter.com/dimitrakhs9 Dimitris Dafalias
-
Rollandmiller
-
http://twitter.com/edwinijsman/status/172943782155792384 Edw!n IJsman
-
http://twitter.com/chicah81/status/172944593942347776 Hijke Schennink
-
http://twitter.com/paularodmod/status/172946066172420097 Paula Rodríguez
-
http://twitter.com/ikarosm/status/172947805760000003 ikaros
-
http://twitter.com/stopthatsound/status/172948449858301952 Stop That Sound
-
http://twitter.com/klarrka/status/172949156833402880 Klara Svejdova
-
http://twitter.com/anapetrovna/status/172949635424456704 Ana Petrovna
-
http://twitter.com/dropthedebt/status/172950152892526592 JubileeDebtCampaign
-
http://twitter.com/top_tw_news/status/172951387443957760 top_tw_news
-
http://twitter.com/charles_tan77/status/172952387462496257 Charles Tan
-
http://twitter.com/vasssilis/status/172958295399743488 vasssilis
-
http://twitter.com/thatarcher/status/172959961876398081 Price-Anderson Act
-
http://twitter.com/apneac/status/172960036434350080 Jurgen
-
http://twitter.com/osmanrk/status/172960055816237056 Osman-Raza Khan
-
http://twitter.com/occupydenhaag/status/172960146304151552 OccupyDenHaag
-
http://twitter.com/ioannaspil/status/172960599330922496 Ioanna Spiliopoulou
-
http://twitter.com/bernat_e/status/172960788728913920 Bernat Escoda
-
http://twitter.com/freiligrad/status/172961052886179840 Dr. Witch
-
http://twitter.com/crowesamuel/status/172961133836251137 Samuel Crowe
-
http://twitter.com/jimrhiz/status/172962056704770048 Jim Richardson
-
http://twitter.com/nicolamoirart/status/172962754024583168 Nicola Moir
-
http://twitter.com/madinmelbourne/status/172964043840176129 Dale Dickins
-
http://twitter.com/nickchatzinick/status/172968961082802176 Nick Chatzinikolaou
-
http://twitter.com/thestoist/status/172970374936530944 Ben Carew
-
http://twitter.com/metacode/status/172971055839846400 metacode
-
http://twitter.com/ietsist/status/172975047403782144 ietsist
-
http://twitter.com/psycharisn/status/172976001419186176 Nektarios Psycharis
-
http://twitter.com/tomgilltweets/status/172976020188696576 tom gill
-
http://twitter.com/er_pashi/status/172976851063537664 Pashi
-
http://twitter.com/sunotissima/status/172976984803119104 Francisco Jurado
-
http://twitter.com/sjvandaalen/status/172977732303593472 Sergey J. van Daalen
-
http://twitter.com/firemanfrittata/status/172977783021125632 Firemanfritter
-
http://twitter.com/t0rst/status/172978237503315969 Torsten Louland
-
http://twitter.com/t0rst/status/172979067732246529 Torsten Louland
-
http://twitter.com/funkage/status/172979620864462848 Martin
-
http://twitter.com/amanda_j_w/status/172980525785554945 Amanda Wilkinson
-
http://twitter.com/arnoudkulk/status/172981277304160256 ArnoudK
-
http://twitter.com/makessensetomee/status/172998544674926592 Colin
-
http://twitter.com/tweetcmw/status/172999332063227905 Charlie Wheeler
-
http://twitter.com/linksverdreher/status/173002658720907265 Gnaeus Flavius III
-
http://twitter.com/blueflake/status/173004885330112512 blueflake
-
http://twitter.com/stewi80/status/173157441545060353 Stephen Wilson
-
http://twitter.com/bossito/status/173167691044102144 bossito
-
http://twitter.com/cascarelo/status/173171126598516738 Cascarelo
-
http://twitter.com/karinwalters/status/173172090197909506 Karin Walters
-
http://twitter.com/nlrevolution/status/173190782134648833 NLRevolution
-
http://twitter.com/faaz71/status/173190898664996866 Sander Faas
-
http://twitter.com/fatdba/status/173192492315967488 Fat DBA
-
http://twitter.com/livvleigh/status/173192676483661824 Liv Leigh
-
http://twitter.com/sachakahn/status/173253589005897728 Sacha Kahn
-
http://twitter.com/arlenehache/status/173284714197692416 Hache Arlene
-
http://twitter.com/riprap007/status/173327234499739648 Nicholas Ripley
-
http://twitter.com/crtivcornercafe/status/173345663671742464 Creative Corner Cafe
-
http://twitter.com/legendarylynn1/status/173364477012623360 Lynn
-
http://twitter.com/scichem_/status/173379625832034304 Jérémy
-
http://twitter.com/calliope_greece/status/173827719660978177 Calliope
-
http://twitter.com/zuzamed/status/173876907744575488 Donato Perretta
-
http://twitter.com/mvkouw/status/174132753464438785 Matthijs Kouw
-
http://twitter.com/maryikon/status/174240174522384384 Mary Ikon
-
http://twitter.com/mor_ile/status/174408053251248128 Ileana Moroni
-
http://greeceandtheimf.wordpress.com/ Keepquestioning
-
http://twitter.com/intina7/status/175287939377537025 Maria J.M.
-
http://www.leftfootforward.org/2012/03/revealed-the-vulture-capitalists-willing-to-destroy-a-nation-for-a-good-return/ Revealed: The vulture capitalists willing to destroy a nation for a good return | Left Foot Forward
-
http://twitter.com/russpress/status/175592180897955840 russpress.net
-
http://twitter.com/abiyooooo/status/175636378103713792 abi ramanan
-
http://twitter.com/mishupishu/status/176014730543112193 MishuPishu
-
http://twitter.com/xtimu/status/176191535598153728 chrisna munlick
-
http://twitter.com/drielsma/status/187156970439057409 Paul HD
-
http://twitter.com/markopeterlin/status/187303462185336832 Marko Peterlin
YouGov Tracker
ToUChstone Economic Tracker
George’s Marvellous Deficit Calculator
Most read this week
- £25bn welfare cuts? Hilton’s plan is absolute nonsense
- Cameron fails to protect frontline staff as promised
- Time for university fat cats to sup from the “efficiency” bowl
- NAO report reveals how Branson ‘Glazered’ taxpayer on Northern Rock
- In Community Relations Week, Northern Ireland’s painful divisions rear their head
Best of the web
Left Foot Facebook
Awards & Rankings
Archive
Tag Cloud
Domestic Progressives
- A Thousand Cuts
- Alastair Campbell
- Andrew Gibson's Blog
- Anthony Painter
- Ayes To The Left
- Blackburn Labour Party
- Chartist
- Conor's Commentary
- Dave's Part
- Diary of a Benefit Scrounger
- Duncan's Economic Blog
- Follow my leaders
- Freemania
- Full Fact
- Go Fourth
- Good Animal / Bad Animal
- Guardian Politics blog
- Harry's Place
- Hopi Sen
- Institute for Government
- Intelligence Squared
- Labour and Capital
- Labour Home
- Labour List
- LabourHome
- Left Central
- Lib-Con Trick
- Liberal Conspiracy
- Liberal Democrat Voice
- LSE politics blog
- Luke's blog
- Mark Thompson Blog
- Matthew Taylor's blog
- Max Atkinson's blog
- Migrants' Rights Network
- New Statesman: free speech
- Next Left
- Nick Pearce
- OurKingdom
- Patrick Bury's blog
- Policy Critical
- Political Reboot
- Political Scrapbook
- Progress
- Red Brick
- RSA Projects
- Runnymede Trust
- Rupa Huq's Blog
- Sadie's Tavern
- Save EMA
- Shamik Das
- Slinger blog
- Speaker’s Chair
- Tank the Tories
- Tax Research UK
- The Centre Left
- The Green Benches
- The Novocastrian
- This is my truth
- Tim McLoughlin
- Tom Harris MP
- Tom Watson MP
- Touchstone
- Touchstone TUC blog
- Young Fabians Blog







