7,262 views
Left Foot Forward > Published by Left Foot Forward, March 5th 2012 at 8:00 am

The document A4E doesn’t want you to see

Print Friendly

 

On Thursday, the website Ipswich Unemployment Action provided a link to an internal A4e document (pdf), that appeared to indicate poor performance on behalf of the embattled welfare-to work company, which has won more than £200million in contracts with the department of work and pensions.

It featured this table:

A4e-document
Before we try to decipher this table, some background information must be outlined.

The top of the document reads:

“This dashboard allows you to view the general health and performance of an office at a glance – however it is a guideline, not the full picture, leaving other factors that must be considered. All data is displayed on a ‘cohort’ basis – as this dashboard is a measure of our performance to customers and our operational practices.”

It is dated throughout 03/01/2012, and the table is headed as ‘Contract to date’. The current work programme contracts were awarded 1st April 2011.

The way the work programme operates is shown in Figure 1 below, from a Department for Work and Pensions document (page 5, pdf). The contracted company is given a fee on taking on an unemployed client. They receive a second fee when that person stays in a job for 26 weeks, and further weekly payments up to a year for every week that person stays in that job.
 
Figure 1:

Incentives-for-sustained-work
Further complicating the work programme is that the government contracts the work to companies like A4e, who then sub-contract it to smaller companies – except in some cases, A4e acts as a subcontractor and not contractor.

The table shows individual results for each of A4e’s partner organisations, of which it is unclear whether they are contractors or subcontractors, that we have blacked out in case we breach commercial confidentiality, with totals at the bottom for the overall programme.

What the table appears to show is that the job entry rate, i.e. the proportion of individuals A4e is responsible for at some level, manages to find a job for, is 8.4 per cent overall and 9.7 per cent if ‘specialists’ – those partners dealing with difficult cases - are excluded.

Meanwhile, the percentage of those who secure a job managing to hold on to that job for 26 weeks, appears to be denoted by the Outcome/Potential Outcome collumn, which has a total of 1.9%, including and excluding difficult cases. If this is the right reading of the table, then it represents a dramatic undershooting of the Department for Work and Pensions’ own targets.

As can be seen from this National Audit Office report (pdf) published in January 2012, the DWP expects 36 per cent of those referred to companies such as A4e to be secured a job for at least 26 weeks (page 4), and 28 per cent of those not on the Work programme to reach this milestone on their own (page 22).

To clarify these  issues, we sent an email to A4e on Thursday as follows:

“Dear [Name],

“Thanks so much for your time before. Please find the attached document, which was made public on the Ipswich Unemployed Action website earlier today.

“Can I confirm that it records the success rates for A4e at different stages of the work programme, as well as for individual partners?

“Can I confirm whether in the relationship between A4e and the partner, who is the contractor and who is the sub-contractor?

“Can I confirm that 8.9 per cent of those on this programme have received a job?

“Can I confirm that the collumn (Outcome) / (Potential Outcomes) refers to those is (numbers of those who have been in continuous employment for 26 weeks since they began their job)/ ( numbers for whom 26 weeks has passed since they began their job)?

“Can I confirm what date the contract started as referred to ‘contract to date’ at the top of each page?

“We would carry any comment from A4e.

“Please let me know what time you can get this to me as we will run in the morning.

“Many thanks

“Dan”

They responded thus:

“Dear Daniel,

“The data was drawn from a test website which is confidential and protected. It is a snapshot in time, and is already out of date. It reflects performance of our partners and not that of A4e.

“It does not in any way provide a fair assessment of Work Programme delivery or success, and to imply otherwise would be highly misleading. It was obtained from a password protected, secure site, in breach of confidentiality.”

“I have copied in our legal representative, Mark Stephens, from Finers Stephens Innocent, who will respond further on this point should you have any further questions. We won’t hesitate to take the strongest legal action should you publish this data or make any of the inferences set out.

“Regards,

“[Name]“

We emailed back asking exactly on what grounds, with reference to which points of law, they would take legal action on our publishing this document, but to no response. In the absence of any response, and with A4e refusing to answer our questions, we leave it to readers to draw their own conclusions.

See also:

• Look Left – A4e: Corruption, fraud and the £200m failure to help the unemployed – Shamik Das, March 2nd 2012

• A4e’s fall from grace has been in the pipeline for two years - Fiona MacTaggart MP, March 2nd 2012

• The government’s got big plans for workfare – don’t expect them to back down easily– Izzy Koksal, February 27th 2012

• The information you need to end workfare - Alex Hern, February 22nd 2012

• Chris Grayling should respond to criticism of workfare, not smear the critics - Izzy Koksal, February 21st 2012

  • http://twitter.com/ian9657/status/176578482116116480 Ian Stuart Goudie

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see, right here: http://t.co/guV416Hn #A4e #workfare

  • http://twitter.com/norock/status/176578955053248512 Simon HB

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see, right here: http://t.co/guV416Hn #A4e #workfare

  • http://twitter.com/jenipurpleness/status/176579472638742528 Jeni Acelas

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see, right here: http://t.co/guV416Hn #A4e #workfare

  • http://twitter.com/k1006hill/status/176579988282294272 ╭∩╮.(︶︿︶).╭∩╮

    "@PatronPress: #UK : The document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/8tfc3DJs"

  • http://twitter.com/judgemenot69/status/176580169534939136 Neil Courtman

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see, right here: http://t.co/guV416Hn #A4e #workfare

  • http://twitter.com/innamood/status/176580737540177920 Inna Mood

    RT "@leftfootfwd: The document A4E doesn’t want you to see, right here: http://t.co/DM4DEXRW #A4e #workfare"

  • http://twitter.com/yrotitna/status/176581178130841600 Yrotitna

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see, right here: http://t.co/guV416Hn #A4e #workfare

  • http://twitter.com/narcodia/status/176581729677606913 Tony Begg

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see, right here: http://t.co/guV416Hn #A4e #workfare

  • http://twitter.com/dantrobus/status/176582003339182080 Danny Antrobus

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see, right here: http://t.co/guV416Hn #A4e #workfare

  • http://twitter.com/_Adi_B Adi_B

    As someone who lost their job working for Seetec due to A4E winning our contract on false premises this does nothing to cheer the mood ! Our ratio of job outcomes was much better than this and although we very rarely met the levels set down when the contract was awarded this was mainly due to the deteriorating Job market in Wolverhampton and not because of inertia on our part.

  • http://twitter.com/acdefyg123/status/176582365647347712 Freddy

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see, right here: http://t.co/guV416Hn #A4e #workfare

  • http://twitter.com/therightarticle/status/176587328465289217 Michael

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see – http://t.co/IpiXqDuT

  • http://twitter.com/cutchswife/status/176587468701839360 cutchswife

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see – http://t.co/IpiXqDuT

  • http://twitter.com/skiptonriponclp/status/176587589808168961 Skipton & Ripon CLP

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/Yr0pRGPQ

  • http://twitter.com/ravensrod/status/176587671320276992 Ferret Dave

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see – http://t.co/IpiXqDuT

  • http://twitter.com/golfartie/status/176587955039764481 arthur jordan

    RT @leftfootfwd: The document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/HJgGFSNu

  • http://twitter.com/jennytwittwoo/status/176588873693020160 Jenny Smith

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see – http://t.co/IpiXqDuT

  • http://twitter.com/labour52rose/status/176589338082152448 Alex Braithwaite

    RT @leftfootfwd: The document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/u0VFidwx

  • http://twitter.com/britishroses1/status/176589997657432064 BevR

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see, right here: http://t.co/guV416Hn #A4e #workfare

  • http://twitter.com/woolfiesmith/status/176590224154046464 Citizen K

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see – http://t.co/IpiXqDuT

  • http://twitter.com/okanynamedoes/status/176590525590274048 Hywel N. Arnold

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see – http://t.co/IpiXqDuT

  • http://twitter.com/vato_rat/status/176595361002029056 Adam

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see, right here: http://t.co/guV416Hn #A4e #workfare

  • http://twitter.com/voraciousvegan/status/176599423164481537 Voracious Vegan

    RT @leftfootfwd The document A4E doesn’t want you to see, right here: http://t.co/aDsTLfDz #A4e #workfare

  • http://twitter.com/vsb69/status/176599479506571264 Fleur

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see, right here: http://t.co/guV416Hn #A4e #workfare

  • http://twitter.com/innerwisdom1/status/176600858098806784 Innerwisdom

    Morning RT: The document A4E doesn’t want you to see: http://t.co/IF8xzuXY #A4e #workfare

  • http://twitter.com/redtom64/status/176601679922339840 Tom Walker

    #A4e shouldn't just be under investigation for fraud. What about their dismal performance in finding people work? http://t.co/QkKHQoGO

  • http://twitter.com/nightsiren/status/176602808739569664 Rosie Walters

    RT @leftfootfwd: The document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/p3WOd1i4

  • http://twitter.com/alan_199/status/176606162731540480 Alan199

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see, right here: http://t.co/guV416Hn #A4e #workfare

  • Ipswich Unemployed Action

    Thanks for posting the data from all those at IUA.

    A4e always threatens legal action – rarely ends up in court.

    When we discovered the a4e performance data, we didn’t email the file across etc. We published links to the source… (if you look at IUA comments, there is a comment with 30 or so links) and at least 26 people downloaded the content from the site, WITHOUT the site being secure, password protected or any non-sense like that.

    If they want to take you to court and lie… THEY WONT. A4e is used to LYING on sanction doubt forms, but unlike sanction doubt forms it is a criminal offence to lie in court.

    As we published the official links, NOT the content obtained originally, there is like I mentioned at least 20 witness statements (assuming a few not coming forward) saying it wasn’t a password protected site etc.

    Since then some kind person has uploaded the documents they obtained to numerous different places to keep them out there. A4e shut their website down (mya4e.com) to prevent further people downloading them as available to all on the web. This failed red faced as by that time all was published to filesharing websites and google docs, for all to view and download.

    Now, trying to cope with pressure from MPs, No10 and DWP they will be threatening ANYONE trying to relay this information further. IUA to date hasn’t received any legal threats for this. Funny that, why would they sue you for linking to the IUA site but not the IUA for finding the information to begin with?

    Typical bullying. They have experienced us before and repeatedly stepped down after proposing legal action. They know they cannot get far with IUA… but maybe their threats is enough to silence and censorship the rest of the web? Nope, didn’t think so, worked for watching A4e though I think.

  • http://twitter.com/joegammie/status/176623810202701825 Joe Gammie

    a4e suggest pursuing legal action as @leftfootfwd publish their results: http://t.co/knohIw3o Surely a public contract has public results?

  • http://twitter.com/skiptonriponclp/status/176624009348255746 Skipton & Ripon CLP

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/Yr0pRGPQ

  • http://twitter.com/shamikdas/status/176624316874637313 Shamik Das

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see, right here: http://t.co/guV416Hn #A4e #workfare

  • http://twitter.com/legalaware/status/176624495086407680 Legal Aware

    Incredibly depressing that many people will have placed their hopes on A4e. http://t.co/RfYKSCw5 from @leftfootfwd

  • http://twitter.com/slingpool/status/176624530658299904 Deborah Ruston

    .@boycottworkfare @ukuncut @mediocredave The document A4E doesn’t want you to see, right here: http://t.co/oDPBlQN7 on @leftfootfwd

  • Anonymous

    Lets get this straight.

    This was NOT obtained either from a test site nor was it password protected in any way. To suggest otherwise would be highly misleading.

    It was actually published to the web via the wordpress upload directory on the A4e main corporate web site.

    I’ll leave the matter of lax IT security, a poorly configured web site and the availability of data (which could be picked up by a simple google web search) to others.

    They know this, as do many IT literate readers.

    Again obfuscation from the masters.

    Regards.

    PS. On the matter of sanctions is it true that A4e are sanctioning at least 10X the rate of the largest WP provider Ingeus? Although the DWP are desperately attempting to not publish this data, we will soon be finding out the truth.

  • http://twitter.com/richswitch/status/176625520459517952 Rich Williams

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/Yr0pRGPQ

  • http://twitter.com/rosenamc/status/176626252462034945 Rosena McKeown

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/Yr0pRGPQ

  • http://twitter.com/jonrivins/status/176626556301611009 Jon Ivins

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/Yr0pRGPQ

  • http://twitter.com/johnnyboy34/status/176626598546636800 Johnny Boy

    .@boycottworkfare @ukuncut @mediocredave The document A4E doesn’t want you to see, right here: http://t.co/oDPBlQN7 on @leftfootfwd

  • http://twitter.com/skiptonriponclp/status/176627725493219328 Skipton & Ripon CLP

    This is the document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/Yr0pRGPQ

  • Foi

    Lets get this straight.

    This was NOT obtained either from a test site nor was it password protected in any way. To suggest otherwise would be highly misleading.

    It was actually published to the web via the wordpress upload directory on the A4e main corporate web site.

    I’ll leave the matter of lax IT security, a poorly configured web site and the availability of data (which could be picked up by a simple google web search) to others.

    Again obfuscation from the masters.

    Regards.

    PS. On the matter of sanctions is it true that A4e are sanctioning at least 10X the rate of the largest WP provider Ingeus? Although the DWP are desperately attempting to not publish this data, we will soon be finding out the truth via an FOI.

  • http://torrentfreak.com/ Rob8urcakes

    I responded to the Labour Government’s public consultation on Welfare Reform about a decade or so ago and specifically warned of this exact type of corrupt and fraudulent behaviour by private-sector work placement providers.

    I also warned that if they were to proceed down the line of using the private-sector in this way rather than our cherished Civil Servants (in Jobcentre’s, DWP etc.) that highly stringent and very frequent auditing would have to be undertaken to prevent fraud.

    So on top of fraud, lying and corruption we now have bullying (which I hadn’t foreseen).

    Good one!!! Keep up the good work folks – you guys are VITAL to showing Parliamentarians that this job belongs firmly in the hands of trusted Civil Servants ONLY.

  • http://twitter.com/riprap007/status/176630586503462912 Nicholas Ripley

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see /by @leftfootfwd http://t.co/03oDFWQj

  • http://twitter.com/riseupuk/status/176632781638615040 RiseUpUK

    .@boycottworkfare @ukuncut @mediocredave The document A4E doesn’t want you to see, right here: http://t.co/oDPBlQN7 on @leftfootfwd

  • http://twitter.com/suellaember/status/176634551592955904 Citizen Ember

    .@boycottworkfare @ukuncut @mediocredave The document A4E doesn’t want you to see, right here: http://t.co/oDPBlQN7 on @leftfootfwd

  • http://twitter.com/bishop_of_souls/status/176635036639051776 God
  • http://twitter.com/bishop_of_souls/status/176635185054490624 God
  • http://twitter.com/bishop_of_souls/status/176635259469836289 God

    @politic_animal http://t.co/TvKXIc3k

  • http://twitter.com/bishop_of_souls/status/176635373131276288 God

    @gethynwilliams http://t.co/TvKXIc3k

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000444368866 David Silverman

    Mark Stephens is a name they pulled out of their arses. He’s a human rights specialist who represented, amongst others, Dave Morris & Helen Steel in the McLibel case, Christopher Hitchens and Richard Dawkins in their prospective legal action against the Pope and Julian Assange in his extradition hearing. It isn’t likely that he’d represent A4e and any letter purporting to come from him is very likely to be a forgery. It’s pure bullshit and is probably actionable in itself. I’d be inclined to reply with a threat to prosecute for attempting to pervert the course of justice.

  • Insider

    At last…A4E had been caught out!

    I too have documents they would wish not to have published relating to suspected fraud concerning the London Mentoring Programme…think I might just pass them on to The Public Accounts Commitee ;-)

  • http://twitter.com/Newsbot9 Newsbot9

    It wouldn’t surprise me at all. After all, they have to try SOMETHING to make up for their worthless actual offering. Time to personally prosecute the A4E directors if it’s the case, of course.

  • Ipswich Unemployed Action

    Interesting… As Emma Harrison CBE always wants her CBE displayed at the end of her name, but A4e doesn’t think Mark Stephens deserves the same…

  • http://twitter.com/n_l_a_t/status/176835600144539648 Nobody likes a Tory

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/VP2SVs9U

  • http://twitter.com/tonethetree/status/176836953537396738 Les Tricoteuses

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see | Left Foot Forward http://t.co/KAlg8Asv

  • http://twitter.com/superlativec/status/176837157049212929 Superlative Siri

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/VP2SVs9U

  • http://twitter.com/ytayj/status/176846209535848448 Yownan Taylor

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/VP2SVs9U

  • http://twitter.com/creativecrip/status/176849476760240128 TheCreativeCrip

    RT @leftfootfwd: The document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/toadidHV

  • http://twitter.com/postpolionews/status/176854780126314498 Chris Salter

    RT @leftfootfwd: The document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/JksXxpws #ppnews #wrb

  • http://twitter.com/hrafndot/status/176855217269252096 Shirley Knott

    RT @leftfootfwd: The document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/toadidHV

  • http://twitter.com/bigtatty/status/176859743678246916 bigtatty

    RT @leftfootfwd: The document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/AruaxCTp

  • http://twitter.com/frdragonspouse/status/176901775293546496 Jill Hayward

    RT @leftfootfwd: The document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/toadidHV

  • http://twitter.com/confieldmartin/status/176930891208208384 Billy Boy

    "The document A4E doesn’t want you to see" http://t.co/rj2bOhIo #A4E #Unemployment #Conservatives

  • http://twitter.com/reigatemedia/status/176957062054547456 Reigate Media

    RT @leftfootfwd: The document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/UvhXSm5q

  • Thehazeyq

    Insane! They’re threatening legal action because you’re holding them to account how they spend public money? Shameful. You have offered them the right to any reply. If they don’t use that it’s their choice and their silence now speaks volumes… Well done, you!!!!

  • http://twitter.com/stonecoldmurphy/status/176996356521594882 anthony murphy

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/uptRRpwN

  • http://twitter.com/b1gnews/status/176996552865361921 b1gnews

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/uptRRpwN

  • http://twitter.com/tobyjlowe/status/177116795084345344 Toby Lowe

    More evidence emerging that the work programme doesn't work: http://t.co/zeuHIyri too early to say "I told you so"?

  • http://twitter.com/dontgetfooled/status/177343585325293569 Richard Wilson

    Ooh – #A4E packing legal threats left right and centre http://t.co/kDdqlmm3 #libelreform

  • http://twitter.com/bunnyrunner/status/177347030862143489 Roger Bliss

    Ooh – #A4E packing legal threats left right and centre http://t.co/kDdqlmm3 #libelreform

  • http://twitter.com/scipoltech/status/177351534366031872 Science Tech Politic

    Ooh – #A4E packing legal threats left right and centre http://t.co/kDdqlmm3 #libelreform

  • http://twitter.com/boycottworkfare/status/177390609210937345 BoycottWorkfare

    Ooh – #A4E packing legal threats left right and centre http://t.co/kDdqlmm3 #libelreform

  • http://twitter.com/nickbloke/status/177391123629744128 Nick H.

    Ooh – #A4E packing legal threats left right and centre http://t.co/kDdqlmm3 #libelreform

  • http://twitter.com/brumprotestor/status/177391207129952256 Brummie Protestor

    Ooh – #A4E packing legal threats left right and centre http://t.co/kDdqlmm3 #libelreform

  • http://twitter.com/number_6_/status/177392114538250240 Number Six

    Ooh – #A4E packing legal threats left right and centre http://t.co/kDdqlmm3 #libelreform

  • http://twitter.com/oxkev Oxford Kevin

    I await a rumour of a super injunction.

  • http://twitter.com/judgemenot69/status/177394795847745537 Neil Courtman

    Ooh – #A4E packing legal threats left right and centre http://t.co/kDdqlmm3 #libelreform

  • http://twitter.com/hillww1/status/177397126328885248 William Hill

    Ooh – #A4E packing legal threats left right and centre http://t.co/kDdqlmm3 #libelreform

  • http://twitter.com/golookgoread/status/177447884655046657 goLookGoRead is:

    Ooh – #A4E packing legal threats left right and centre http://t.co/kDdqlmm3 #libelreform

  • http://twitter.com/russellcavanagh/status/177456580856516608 Russell Cavanagh

    Ooh – #A4E packing legal threats left right and centre http://t.co/kDdqlmm3 #libelreform

  • http://twitter.com/lewiepsmummy/status/177476637342957568 shirley procter

    Ooh – #A4E packing legal threats left right and centre http://t.co/kDdqlmm3 #libelreform

  • http://twitter.com/davesmith40uk/status/177509494824255488 David Smith

    @BBCFreeSpeech A4E work programme performance exposed : http://t.co/oK4hAxQf Not that you will mention it of course #workfare

  • http://twitter.com/davesmith40uk/status/177801415148834816 David Smith

    @FSILaw Was Mark Stephens CBE copied in as the legal representative for #A4E as reported in this article : http://t.co/oK4hAxQf ? #workfare

  • http://twitter.com/davesmith40uk/status/177804528958177282 David Smith

    @he_gray Was Mark Stephens CBE copied in as the legal representative for #A4E as reported in this article : http://t.co/oK4hAxQf ? #workfare

  • http://twitter.com/davesmith40uk/status/177806600411676672 David Smith

    @TweetLands Was Mark Stephens CBE copied in as the legal rep for #A4E as reported in this article http://t.co/oK4hAxQf ? #workfare

  • http://www.refusewp.com/solidarity.IUA/A4e-Work-Programme-Performance/Poor-Performance.html Ipswich Unemployed Action

    If you want to see a larger image click the above link… with provider names also :)

  • http://twitter.com/stewartgregg/status/178151315229257728 Stewart Gregg

    The document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/wMhIryxm

  • http://www.leftfootforward.org/2012/03/look-left-09-03-12/ Look Left – Spotlight shone on legal aid cuts as Clarke urged to think again | Left Foot Forward

    [...] week’s most read: 1. The document A4E doesn’t want you to see – Left Foot [...]

  • David Davies

    This kind of sneering job snobbery at thrusting private sector fulfillment in response to the abject failure of pubic sector inertia and incompetence is typical of the nitpicking naysayers who would stifle enterprise.

    We NEED these heroic entrepreneurs to ` hugely incentivise’ themselves, and make optional contributions of their notional tax liability – otherwise we will lose these heroes to the far corners. Then, where would we be?

    The 99%ers pay tax, unless on workfare – that is the order of things – and those who care for and cure others must be offered a pittance, because their chosen careers are vocational. You can’t enjoy what you do AND get paid a living wage as well – where would it all end?

  • http://twitter.com/ncacnews/status/178635899167444993 NCAC

    @leftfootfwd: The document A4E doesn’t want you to see, right here: http://t.co/XXS38OjL #A4e #workfare

  • http://twitter.com/boffchops/status/179038387292999680 Jay Thompson

    @leftfootfwd: The document A4E doesn’t want you to see, right here: http://t.co/XXS38OjL #A4e #workfare

  • http://twitter.com/redjolly1/status/179295868762071042 Debbie Jolly

    RT @MasonDAutistic RT @leftfootfwd: The document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/mb2tRIFV

  • http://twitter.com/lisakef/status/179298051582734336 lisa lou

    RT @MasonDAutistic RT @leftfootfwd: The document A4E doesn’t want you to see http://t.co/mb2tRIFV

  • http://twitter.com/puffles2010/status/179908091259793408 The Dragon Fairy

    Q 2 Clegg on A4e – here's the document they don't want you to see: http://t.co/5KJlmSHs #PMQs

  • http://twitter.com/alph_soup_hull/status/179908295828582400 DJs Han and Beav

    Q 2 Clegg on A4e – here's the document they don't want you to see: http://t.co/5KJlmSHs #PMQs

  • http://twitter.com/pinkmurf/status/179908482399612930 Murph

    Q 2 Clegg on A4e – here's the document they don't want you to see: http://t.co/5KJlmSHs #PMQs

  • http://twitter.com/stevescullion/status/179909073918107648 Stephen Scullion

    Q 2 Clegg on A4e – here's the document they don't want you to see: http://t.co/5KJlmSHs #PMQs

  • http://twitter.com/innamood/status/179909132852269060 Inna Mood

    Q 2 Clegg on A4e – here's the document they don't want you to see: http://t.co/5KJlmSHs #PMQs

  • http://twitter.com/vato_rat/status/179909546372894720 Adam

    Q 2 Clegg on A4e – here's the document they don't want you to see: http://t.co/5KJlmSHs #PMQs

  • http://twitter.com/innerwisdom1/status/179910869784858624 Innerwisdom

    Q 2 Clegg on A4e – here's the document they don't want you to see: http://t.co/5KJlmSHs #PMQs

  • http://twitter.com/psychoticlynx/status/179911135770853376 Kim Blake

    Q 2 Clegg on A4e – here's the document they don't want you to see: http://t.co/5KJlmSHs #PMQs

  • http://twitter.com/macinpoole/status/179921481717911553 malcolm

    Q 2 Clegg on A4e – here's the document they don't want you to see: http://t.co/5KJlmSHs #PMQs

  • http://twitter.com/nickbloke/status/179946098184560641 Nick H.

    Q 2 Clegg on A4e – here's the document they don't want you to see: http://t.co/5KJlmSHs #PMQs

  • http://twitter.com/creativecrip/status/180369870985240576 TheCreativeCrip

    .@boycottworkfare @ukuncut @mediocredave The document A4E doesn’t want you to see, right here: http://t.co/oDPBlQN7 on @leftfootfwd

  • http://twitter.com/steveturner02/status/180379347490844672 steve turner

    .@boycottworkfare @ukuncut @mediocredave The document A4E doesn’t want you to see, right here: http://t.co/oDPBlQN7 on @leftfootfwd

  • http://www.leftfootforward.org/2012/03/newsnight-leaked-a4e-document-reveals-systemic-fraud/ New report reveals “devastating evidence of systemic fraud within A4e” | Left Foot Forward

    [...] readers will recall that, earlier this month, A4e tried to prevent Left Foot Forward from publishing an internal document (pdf) that appeared to indicate poor performance on behalf of [...]

  • http://www.leftfootforward.org/2012/05/work-programme-subcontracting-fail/ Charity survey shows up shambolic work programme | Left Foot Forward

    [...] The document A4e doesn’t want you to see 5 Mar [...]

  • http://twitter.com/deerd08/status/202404719090601984 Deirdre Campbell

    Is Grayling throwing out the termination of ONE A4e contract as a sop ahead of new NAO report? Some prior A4e links > http://t.co/WGcNhFLo

  • http://twitter.com/deerd08/status/202405652839149568 Deirdre Campbell

    Is Grayling throwing out the termination of ONE #A4e contract as a sop ahead of new NAO report? Some prior A4e links > http://t.co/WGcNhFLo

  • http://twitter.com/seventimestom/status/202407664297320448 Thomas Milman

    Is Grayling throwing out the termination of ONE #A4e contract as a sop ahead of new NAO report? Some prior A4e links > http://t.co/WGcNhFLo

  • http://www.leftfootforward.org/2012/05/government-fires-disgraced-a4e/ Fired! Government gives disgraced A4e the boot | Left Foot Forward

    [...] The document A4E doesn’t want you to see 5 Mar [...]